Ring boy scandal

The ring boy scandal was a sex scandal in the World Wrestling Federation (WWF; now known as WWE) centered around allegations that in the late 1980s and early 1990s ring announcer Mel Phillips (1941–2012) had recruited teenage boys for the purposes of sexual exploitation. The scandal, which came at a time of turmoil for WWF – at the same time, they were suspected of supplying illegal steroids to their wrestlers – resulted in the dismissal of Phillips, Terry Garvin and, temporarily, Pat Patterson in 1992.

Background and initial allegations

WWE, then known as the World Wrestling Federation – is a professional wrestling promotion based in Stamford, Connecticut; from its foundation in 1953 until its 2023 sale to Endeavor, it was owned and operated by the McMahon family. In 1982, Vince McMahon bought the promotion from his father and underwent an aggressive national expansion which effectively made WWF the leading promotion in the country, and later, the world.

As was standard within the wrestling industry at the time, WWF would routinely recruit young men as gofers; in particular, they would be asked to help set up the ring before events. Mel Phillips, who appeared on-screen as a ring announcer, was tasked with managing the ring crew. In 1992, one such "ring boy", Tom Cole, went public with allegations of sexual abuse against WWF, which were initially broken in the New York Post by sports journalist Phil Mushnick on February 26, 1992.

Cole initially started working for WWF in 1983 at the age of thirteen, initially working at house shows in Westchester County, New York before being hired for events in New York City, and eventually, other major cities along the Northeast Corridor. Cole was a runaway from a single-parent home, and alleged that Phillips would encourage him to recruit other boys from broken homes for ring work. According to a draft legal complaint against WWF, Phillips engaged engaging in fetishistic play with Cole's feet, including rubbing them against his genitals, and that other boys had similar experiences.

Cole also alleged that Terry Joyal – who wrestled for the WWF under the ring name Terry Garvin and was Phillips' supervisor backstage – had sexually harassed him twice as a teenager. On the first occasion in 1988, Joyal allegedly solicited Cole on a car trip to Massachusetts and offered him alcohol and drugs; after rebutting the advances, Cole was not offered further work for some time. On the second occasion, in 1990, Joyal allegedly solicited Cole for oral sex; after Cole rejected the advances again, Phillips rescinded a job offer to Cole, supposedly on Joyal's orders. In a 2020 statement to Business Insider, WWE attorney Jerry McDevitt confirmed the second incident did take place, but denied that it was indicative of a culture of child sexual abuse, as Cole was nineteen years old at the time. Cole also made similar accusations of sexual harassment against Joyal's boss Pat Patterson, another veteran wrestler and a member of McMahon's inner circle.

The scandal

In response to Mushnick's story, the WWF issued a statement that it would "take responsible action regarding any legitimate claims filed through lawful channels"; on March 2, Joyal, Patterson, and Phillips all resigned their roles in the company. At the same time, Mushnick alleged that McMahon had telephoned him and said that Phillips had been initially dismissed in 1988 because he had a "peculiar and unnatural" relationship with the ring boys, had been re-hired several months later if Phillips promised to "steer clear from kids", and that Phillips would not be offered his job back in the light of the scandal.

On March 11, The San Diego Union-Tribune published an article that not only mentioned Cole's allegations, but also summarised the ongoing steroid use scandal and allegations by former WWF wrestler Barry Orton and former announcer Murray Hodgson against Joyal and Patterson. The story also included allegations by another former ring boy, Chris Loss, who alleged "boys are getting propositioned and played with all the time", but that ring boys "put up with it" because WWF generously paid them.

On March 13, Cole's attorney Alan Fuchsberg sent a draft copy of a legal complaint to WWF, seeking $3.5 million in restitution. Two days later, Cole and Fuchsberg met with Vince McMahon, his wife Linda, and WWF's counsel Jerry McDevitt at Fuchsberg's offices in Manhattan. According to Cole in an 1999 interview, he initially offered to settle for approximately $750,000, but eventually acquiesced to a settlement that would see him re-hired by WWF with backpay.

A day later, Vince McMahon appeared for a taping of The Phil Donahue Show, with Hodgson, Orton, former WWF wrestlers Bruno Sammartino and "Superstar" Billy Graham, and wrestling journalist Dave Meltzer also appearing on the panel. According to Cole, the McMahons engineered his attendance at the taping so the settlement could be announced, but were unable to do so as Donahue did not mention him by name. In the following week's issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Meltzer recounted his appearance on the show – including a supposed confrontation between Cole and Sammartino and Graham after the taping – and stated that rumours surrounding Joyal and Phillips dated back to at least the mid-1980s, as well as corroborating other aspects of Mushnick's reporting.

Aftermath

Despite Cole withdrawing his complaints, 1992 continued to be a year of turmoil for WWF. The scandal broke in the run-up to both the debut of McMahon's new World Bodybuilding Federation (WBF) on television on April 4 and WrestleMania VIII on April 5. On April 2, the Department of Justice formally subpoenaed the WWF in regards to the steroid scandal, and on April 3, former WWF referee Rita Chatterton appeared on Geraldo Rivera's talk show Now It Can Be Told and alleged that McMahon had raped her in 1986. Later in that year, McMahon separately sued Chatterton and Mushnick for defamation; the lawsuits would end inconclusively. The WBF folded in July 1992, McMahon was indicted, prosecuted, and eventually acquitted of illegally supplying steroids to WWF wrestlers over the next two years, and WWF's business would decline during the mid-1990s as they struggled to replace their most popular star Hulk Hogan, who had also been implicated in the steroid scandal.

Joyal's and Phillips' careers ended after the scandal, but Patterson was offered his job back after Hodgson retracted his allegations, and stayed with WWE for most of the rest of his life until his death from cancer in 2020. The FBI investigated Phillips and identified ten potential victims, but did not press charges as none of them were willing to testify as to the nature of his activities. Cole was fired in 1993 after failing conditions related to his re-employment. In that same year, he filed a lawsuit against WWF, Joyal, Patterson, and Phillips; the lawsuit was dismissed a year later. Cole died from suicide in 2021, at the age of 50. Phillips and WWE would be sued by a third ring boy in 1999; the case was eventually settled a year later.

Linda McMahon served as WWE president and CEO from 1993 until her resignation from the company in 2009 in order to campaign to become the U.S. Senator for Connecticut in the 2010 elections. When reached for comment by Politico in 2010, Cole approvingly spoke of her role in his situation and endorsed her campaign. McMahon was unsuccessful in both the 2010 and 2012 elections. She was later nominated by Donald Trump – a life-long friend to the McMahon family – to lead the Small Business Administration, a role she held between February 2017 and April 2019. During the vetting process, Trump's transition team highlighted "WWE's alleged culture of sexual abuse" – including the ring boy scandal – as a possible red flag, but the issue was never raised during her confirmation hearings.

Vince McMahon was eventually ousted as WWE CEO in 2022 after the WWE's board of directors found that McMahon had made hush money payments totalling $12 million to several women who alleged sexual misconduct against him. He would temporarily return in January 2023 to oversee the company's sale to Endeavor, but was ousted yet again in January 2024 after one of the women concerned, Janel Grant, alleged that McMahon had raped and trafficked her.

The ring boy scandal received renewed attention after the release of the 2024 Netflix documentary miniseries Mr. McMahon, which covered the 1992 scandals in its second episode. After the series aired, five John Does collectively sued the WWE and both Linda and Vince McMahon for negligence, alleging that Phillips assaulted and groomed them at various points during the 1980s, and that the McMahons "knew or should have known" about Phillips' actions, but instead "knowingly fostered and allowed a culture of sexual misconduct to permeate the WWE".

See also

• Ashley Massaro, a former WWE wrestler who alleged that the company covered up her rape;
• Speaking Out movement, a social movement against sexual abuse in the professional wrestling industry