Talk:11-cell

Latest comment: 7 years ago by Chin Yeh in topic The 11 cells on the 1st diagram

The 11 cells on the 1st diagram

edit

On the 2nd row 1st cell, the colors blue and purple seem need be switched. Chin Yeh (talk) 16:08, 16 April 2017 (UTC)Reply

Schläfli symbol?

edit

The symbol Schläfli symbol {3,5,3} is apparently shared with a hyperbolic honeycomb: Order-3_icosahedral_honeycomb

Can anyone help explain this? I just saw an article about this in Discover Magazine, although it didn't list this symbol.

Tom Ruen 05:57, 12 March 2007 (UTC)Reply

The symbol {3,5,3} as you probably know means [3-gons, 5 per vertex, 3 of these things around an edge]. This important information is not at all a complete description of the geometric object it describes. Even the Schläfli symbol for the icosahedron, {3,5}, is shared by the hemi-icosahedron -- a triangulation of the projective plane by 6 triangles that is the relevant "height 3" object in the abstract regular polytope called the 11-cell, also known as the "hendecatope". (Some people avoid the "-choron" suffix in favor of the more general "-tope" simply because "-tope" uses only one syllable.)
As for the {3,5,3} hyperbolic honeycomb, this is a way of tessellating (all of) hyperbolic 3-space by regular hyperbolic icosahedra of the unique size such that their dihedral angles are all 120 degrees, enabling them to fit 3 around each edge (as the right-hand 3 in {3,5,3} requires).
But for the 11-cell, the symbol {3,5,3} signifies that there are 3 hemi-icosahedra around each edge. Because the projective plane is not the boundary of any 3-dimensional manifold, it is not clear (at least to me) whether there is any natural embedding of the 11-cell (in a larger space) that preserves its metric and symmetry. It is the union of 11 hemi-icosahedra with their 110 triangles identified in pairs, resulting in a total of 11 vertices, 55 edges, 55 triangles, and 11 hemi-icosahedra with its symmetry group transitive on flags, and therefore containing 660 symmetries; this group is isomorphic to PSL(2,11).Daqu 22:37, 19 May 2007 (UTC)Reply
You can embedd it in 10-space as a hendecaxennon, but then the hemi-icosahedral cells are skew. Not sure if it's possible to embedd it in a lower-dimensional Euclidean space. Professor M. Fiendish, Esq. 09:39, 8 September 2009 (UTC)Reply

"constructed by pasting hemi-icosahedra together"

edit

How do you paste hemi-icosahedra together? Surely they can't be made in the real world, which has the wrong topology for that (at the human scale, at least)! Double sharp (talk) 09:13, 19 August 2012 (UTC)Reply

Error in diagram?

edit

In the diagram "Hemi-icosahedron_coloured.svg", I think there is a mistake. The six cells surrounding the "t" vertex are coloured red, blue, oink, yellow, orange and grey. However, the diagram for the yellow cell has a purple face adjacent to the "t" vertex. By elimination, I think it should be blue. Apt1002 (talk) 19:20, 7 September 2013 (UTC)Reply