Talk:Alwina Gossauer

Latest comment: 9 years ago by Lopifalko in topic Sources and claimed further references

Sources and claimed further references

edit

Hi, thx for your improvements in spelling and grammar, and, couriosly, even just two viewings, but in that short time, four editors, no further links to the wiki, strange Wiki statistics tools as per Sept 9 19:00 Swiss local time...

  Comment: related to claimed additional sources: honestly, two books (!) that document Alwina Gossauer's work, three references and an additional weblink (!) and one exhibition, and some gxxle hits icluding also her photographs, imho "enough" for an encyclopedic sourced stub just started hours ago... consider, Alwina Gossauer was "just" a hard working lady photographer in the mid-1860s in puritan Switzerland, no support by the public or even any prominent noble patrons, in fact, no one was "interested to document" her success at that time men's world, except her photographs. So there's time, i look for further material, btw: the man now redlinked, imho is not encyclopedic. thx and bye, Roland zh (talk) 17:15, 9 September 2015 (UTC)Reply

What brought this articleto my attention was you adding it to List of photographers. A biography of a person needs to demonstrate their notability, using reliable references - that is just Wikipedia policy. I added the redlink for Karl Stalder as much to show that he was not notable as that he was, because my reading of your text was that it hinted at his notability. -Lopifalko (talk) 18:30, 9 September 2015 (UTC)Reply