Talk:Atul Gawande/GA2
GA Review
edit| GA toolbox |
|---|
| Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Psiĥedelisto (talk · contribs) 07:26, 17 September 2021 (UTC)
@BennyOnTheLoose: This article has a complicated history vis-à-vis the GAN process. Vrrajkum first requested GA. He didn't have time to implement changes, and after a 2O by Larry Hockett, (which seems to have partly been requested to give him more time—clever if you ask me), the article was failed. The original editor never returned, but then BennyOnTheLoose adopted first the article, and then the GAN. I can almost pass this, but two details failed verification. Also, minor comment, citation style could use work… especially citations four through six, which have stuff like "www.hsph.harvard.edu" in the website field and not Harvard T. H. Chan School of Public Health. However, the failed verifications are going to be the reason I'll have to fail this in a week if you can't get to it. (No 2O request this time. 😉) Psiĥedelisto (talk • contribs) please always ping! 14:21, 18 September 2021 (UTC)
- Hi Psiĥedelisto. Thanks for taking on the review and for your edits. I've amended the source for the Hasting Centre fellowship and removed the fv tag from there. For the Reith Lectures, I've removed the "annual" bit as that isn't essential IMO, and I believe that the source now supports the info there. (If you click "show more" on ref 38, it says "This first of four lectures was recorded before an audience at the John F Kennedy Presidential Library and Museum in Dr. Gawande's home town of Boston in Massachusetts. The other lectures are recorded in London, Edinburgh and Delhi.") but I've kept the fv tag there in case I've misunderstood what failed verification. I've amended the website parameters in a few citations. Let me know about anything else that is required. (Oh, and one thing more to add to that article history - it was me that requested the second opinion. I think I addressed everything that was in the original reviews except adding that "Gawande provided advice on reopening schools amid COVID-19", as that seemed to lack sustained coverage.) Regards, BennyOnTheLoose (talk) 19:04, 18 September 2021 (UTC)
- @BennyOnTheLoose: Thanks for the quick work! Luckily not much at all remained as this article is very well written. I imagine the only reason it languished from July to now over on WP:GAN is the complicated history of its journey to GA status. Sorry about the error on the second {{failed verification}} tag, I don't know what happened there other than human error as explained in the WP:ES. Yes, I did note that you requested the 2O, I thought it was nice of you to give the requester more time when they explained their situation, and your reason anyway for wanting one was valid, but it wasn't essential so I just think it was a nice thing. Anyway, without further ado
:
- @BennyOnTheLoose: Thanks for the quick work! Luckily not much at all remained as this article is very well written. I imagine the only reason it languished from July to now over on WP:GAN is the complicated history of its journey to GA status. Sorry about the error on the second {{failed verification}} tag, I don't know what happened there other than human error as explained in the WP:ES. Yes, I did note that you requested the 2O, I thought it was nice of you to give the requester more time when they explained their situation, and your reason anyway for wanting one was valid, but it wasn't essential so I just think it was a nice thing. Anyway, without further ado
Good Article review progress box
|
- Psiĥedelisto (talk • contribs) please always ping! 20:46, 18 September 2021 (UTC)