Talk:Báthory family (of the Aba clan)

Criteria for the article

By which criteria is this article different from the Báthory family article? No source delineates the 2 as something special. Aba lineage is only thought to be the origin of the family, it is not a different "clan" or family from the "regular" Báthorys. This would mean this is a duplicate article, best incorporated in the existing one or just deleted if superfluous. Kkupus (talk) 20:58, 27 September 2024 (UTC)

This discussion in the huwiki Village Pump seems to reflect that, as they explicitly call it a "hoax". While this may be bias due to the author previously publishing original research (some of which seems to be in this article, dealing with Tibor Báthory-Szőny), I have perused some of the sources, and they mostly establish a genealogical connection between Báthory and Aba (though the very first source mentions a relative lack of data for this in its Discussion), and not the existence of a family separate from Báthory. I also cannot help but notice that most of the article is written like an essay with links to personal documents about the family obtained by the author at request from various Hungarian authorities, which is fixable, but doesn't help the WP:OR problem. Hijérovīt | ^þⰁ_č 15:42, 28 September 2024 (UTC)