Talk:BC Kosher

Re "Like an advertisement"

The text of the article refers to "our products" so it cannot be an independent peer-reviewed WP entry. A strong dose of deletion here would improve the encyclopedia.--SilasW (talk) 20:43, 20 October 2009 (UTC)

Advert/Cultural vanity

The article adheres to few WP guidelines. Its title is "BC Kosher" but it starts "The BC Kosher emblem is an internationally recognized trademark of BC Kosher Supervision, one of the primary kosher certification agencies."

• The BC Kosher emblem ne. BC Kosher
• What emblem? If its use is so closely guarded that WP can't show it then the article is as pointless as one about my uncle George.
• Is the emblem so powerful in the minds of those who use it that even to show it in an encyclopedia article would make that article, which anyone may edit, halal?
• What international bodies (outside Jewry) even know of it? I have never heard of it in the half a dozen countries I have lived in.
• I suppose WP has to have articles about superstitions and cultural behaviours but they should state something like "Some people believe that ......." for there is no WP standard evidence for them.--SilasW (talk) 18:32, 27 October 2009 (UTC)