Talk:Chill guy

Latest comment: 3 days ago by Royiswariii in topic Bluesky source

Before undoing my edits please consider

edit

Tweets from the brands using the meme are used as sources for the post, why should the official artist's Tumblr not be considered a source but brand Twitters are? Avienby (talk) 03:57, 24 November 2024 (UTC)Reply

@Avienby Because they are not WP:SECONDARY sources, and sourcing information using only primary sources does not establish it's notability in the article. I believe that even if you did find a secondary source talking about Bank's merch, it still may violate WP:NOTPROMO, but it depends on how well its neutrally phrased. Oh, and you're completely right that using a brand's own tweet/reel/post would be a primary source as well, which for some reason I wasn't thinking about. I'm removing that information now. Thanks for the heads up, and cheers from another fan of chill guy 🙂 Johnson524 05:24, 24 November 2024 (UTC)Reply

Bluesky source

edit

Hello @Royiswariii: I hope you are well 🙂 I see you added an unreliable sources tag on the page, and I wanted to ask you about your reasoning for doing so so I can fix the issue and remove the tag. The source in question on BlueSky was made by the author of the artwork, and comments on the one mistake he saw on this specific Wikipedia page, being that his artwork wasn't based on anything like it was reported. I wouldn't consider this statement an "exceptional claim" that would violate WP:ABOUTSELF, but what do you think? Especially since the author made this comment on BlueSky as a way to help clarify some incorrect information on how he made his art, I think it's important to be kept, but if you still disagree I can remove it. Cheers! Johnson524 07:18, 30 November 2024 (UTC)Reply

Hello, Johnson524! I'm being neutral that the "exceptional claim" should be applied, however, Bluesky is a social media and inspired from Twitter and it's on WP:SOCIALMEDIA. But, if you want to keep the source, you should search some support reliable sources of articles on he claims. Thanks! Royiswariii Talk! 07:28, 30 November 2024 (UTC)Reply