Talk:Circumcision/Archive guide

Anyone may add links here to talk page discussions that people might want to refer back to.

Title of article

• 47. Name
• 46. Cherchez la femme (Summary by Avi)
• 40. Requested move (Poll)
• Talk:Circumcision and law#Neutrality
• 34. Why only male circumcision?
• 34. RfC: Is circumcision synonymous with male circumcision?

Tags

• Talk:Circumcision/Archive 53#Straw poll: should tags be removed? is now a subsection of Talk:Circumcision/Archive 53#Possible bias?
• 52. TotallyDisputed tag
• 48. Tags

Hatnote

• 48. Female circumcision in hatnote

Lead

First sentence

"surgical"

• 27. Circumcision is not Surgery
• 41. Circumcision is, of course, surgery
• 50. "Surgical" in first sentence

Prevalence

• 33. Why reference just WHO estimate?
• 37. random countries/confusion of prevalence/incidence

Frenectomy in lead

• 45. Frenectomy
• 30. Frenectomy in the intro paragraph
• 29. Avi reverts away frenectomy
• 16. Frequency of frenectomy

Controversy in lead

• 38. opponents vs. advocates
• 50. Defining the controversy
• 48. Lead
• 59. Advocate versus advocates

Extreme pain

• 50. Source says "excruciating pain." Why can't we?

Info on circumcision in English speaking countries

• 48. Info on circumcision in English speaking countries
• 51. removal of info on medical circ rates in English speaking countries

Prevalence of circumcision

• Talk:Circumcision/Archive_42#Prevalence_map 42. 3 discussions on prevalence map

Modern circumcision procedures

Disposition of severed foreskins

• 51. 'Foreskin-based medical and consumer products' section

History of circumcision

Early Christianity

• 44. Rejection of circumcision by early Christians

Circumcision in the English-speaking world

• 31. Circumcision_prevalent.2C_not_necessarily_customary

Kellogg

• Talk:Circumcision#Problematic addition to 'history'
• Talk:Circumcision/Archive_15#Kellog

Ethical, psychological and legal considerations

Medical aspects

Pain and pain relief during circumcision

Ethics quote

• 45. Pain or ethics

Sexual effects of circumcision

• 14. Sexual Effects
• 45. Contains links to previous discussions too

Complications from circumcision

Meatal stenosis

• 47. Meatal Stenosis

Sexually transmitted diseases

Human immunodeficiency virus

• 35. What studies to include
• 48. HIV section

Valiere Alcena

• 48. Intro to HIV section
• 48. Is this relevant?

Keratin and Langerhans cells

• 51. Keratin and Langerhans cells
• Paring back the WHO info, ROUND II; re keratin, also re HIV rewrite

Penile cancer

• Penile Cancer myth

Policies of various national medical associations

Circumcision opposition

• 32. Should there be a criticism section?

Circumcision promotion

• RFC on whether Circumcision advocacy page should be deleted

External links

• 48. High quality external links

Images

Plastibell image

• 45. Image in Circumcision procedures section

Image of circumcision of Jesus

• 45. Image of circumcision of Jesus

Image of protest

• 40. Talk:Circumcision#Ethical Issues Image

Images of penises

• 51. Pornographic photos of penises

Accusations of pro-circumcision bias

General bias

• 38.Highly Biased Article
• 20. Several sections on subject of pro circ bias
• 33. Example_of_POV-forking.

Article Length

• 32. Article too long?

Structure

• 27. Tipt comparison

Types of circumcision: therapeutic, infant etc.

• 47. Intro to medical policies section

On what is a reliable source

letters to medical journals

• Talk:reliable sources - Letters to the editor of peer-reviewed journals: automatically reliable?
• 31. Dispute over using a letter by user:jakew