Talk:Destroying angel (Bible)

Latest comment: 6 months ago by --peter.josvai in topic The section "The Islamic view" is problematic

Expanding the Stub

edit

What do fellow Wikipedians think about moving this stub to "Angels of Punishment"? It could cover much more, than just the few references to "angels of destruction" in the Bible, if we do so. It could also merge with the Zabaniyya article (hell angels or demons in Islam, also called angels of punishment). It seems both have their origins in the "satans" of 1 Enoch. If we do so, it could be extented with a "bible" section, a "Judaism" section and an "Islam" section (with corresponding subsections) and added to the "angels in abrahamic religions" template.--VenusFeuerFalle (talk) 21:01, 7 May 2020 (UTC)Reply

The section "The Islamic view" is problematic

edit

It is problematic because a section like this could be attached to ANY topic... anytime, anywhere...


This is a Jewish story... in the Torah...


A chapter called Islamic or Christian reference could be totally okay...

But adding the Islamic View (of the Jewish Torah) has no relevance in terms of history and science and culture....


Let's no play religious games! :)

Let's focus on knowledge, and history, as it happened...


with respect,


--peter.josvai (talk) 17:44, 23 April 2024 (UTC)Reply