Wikipedia

Talk:Disturbia (song)/GA1

< Talk:Disturbia (song)
Latest comment: 13 years ago by Basilisk4u in topic GA Review

GA Review

edit
Latest comment: 13 years ago66 comments4 people in discussion
GA toolbox
Reviewing

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Basilisk4u (talk · contribs) 01:11, 6 November 2011 (UTC)Reply

Hey! I am going to review this article. Yay! Basilisk4u (talk) 01:11, 6 November 2011 (UTC)Reply

Notes

edit
Lead
  • "It impacted US Contemporary hit radio on June 17, 2008" --> It debuted on US Contemporary hit radio
  • "'Disturbia' is an uptempo dance-electro-pop song with a sizzling, sturdy beat." I found that one of the sources referred to the beat as

"sizzling" - this should be in quotes. I am not sure if any of your sources necessarily refer to the beat as "sturdy"

  • "The song has club and dancefloor-like qualities, that recall of Rihanna's 2007 single 'Don't Stop the Music'." --> The song has club and dancefloor-like qualities reminiscent of Rihanna's 2007 single "Don't Stop the Music".
  • "Lyrically, the song explains the strange fears that Rihanna possesses." This sentence is a bit strange. From what I got from the Background section, the song discusses the general experiences of anguish, anxiety and confusion. Perhaps you could reword the sentence to express this.
  • "In the US, Billboard ranked the song at number nine on their list of 'Songs of the Summer of 2008'." Since Billboard is a magazine, it should be "its" instead of "their", so it should be "In the US, Billboard ranked the song at number nine on its 'Songs of the Summer of 2008' list."
  • "Also, About.com ranked the song..." Also --> Additionally - sounds a little better in my opinion
  • "The song also reached the top-ten in more than twenty countries including Australia, Austria, Canada, Denmark, France, Germany, Norway, Spain, Switzerland, United Kingdom among others." I think listing the countries is a bit much, maybe leave the countries out and combine the sentence with the sentence before it - "The song was a commercial success, reaching number one in Belgium (Flanders) and New Zealand, and becoming a top-ten hit in more than twenty countries."
  • "It portrays Rihanna in a prison cell, wearing lenses that make her eyes roll into the back of her head." Not sure if the lenses part is really necessary for the lead.
Background
  • "Disturbia" was originally written by Rihanna's ex-boyfriend Chris Brown and his team" If I'm not mistaken, weren't Rihanna and Chris dating at the time? If they were, it is more concise to use "then-boyfriend"
  • "In an interview on This Morning, Rihanna also said that the song is not necessarily about a personal experience. She said it was about mental anguish, anxiety and confusion." This should probably be one sentence --> "In an interview on This Morning, Rihanna said that the song is not necessarily about a specific personal experience, but rather the general feelings of mental anguish, anxiety and confusion."
  • "Rihanna further explained that she wanted to record the song because its topic is something that affects many people at one time or another." --> "Rihanna further explained that she wanted to record the song because she felt that listeners would be able to relate to the subject matter."
  • This is just a curiosity, but do you know of any connection between the song and the movie Disturbia? Because when I heard it the first time, I was wondering about that. This is not required for the GA though haha
Actually I didn't met any source saying that the both of them are connected. :) So I don't think there is a connection between them. — Tomica1111 • Question Existing? 09:35, 12 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
Composition
  • Same thing about the sizzling, sturdy beat - should be in quotes and the link to the source about it being sturdy appears to have died :(
Critical reception
  • "'Disturbia' is Rihanna's most progressive and confident vocal to-date, ringing the authority of an established star." - displaying the authority
  • All references to magazine lists should use "its" instead of "their"
  • "however after a certain mash-up, Katy Perry accepted the award for her single 'I Kissed A Girl'." --> "however, after a miscommunication, Katy Perry..."
Chart performance

Looks fine :D

Music video
  • "First, it was reported that originally the video was directed by American photographer and director, David LaChapelle" --> "Originally, it was reported that the video was directed..."
Live performances

Great job!

There are actually quite a lot of issues in this section. Keep the review open please, I will comment within 12/15 hours. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 01:05, 12 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
Actually, I just read the article through as a whole, and there is a lot of poor phrasing and word choices throughout the article. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 01:14, 12 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
Sourcing

Okay I have finished the review and put it on hold :)

Comments by Calvin999

edit
Info box
  • Change the length parameter from 3:58 to {{Duration|m=3|s=58}}
Lead
  • → "from the re-release"
  • → "released as the third single"
  • → ""Disturbia" was released to US Contemporary hit radio"
  • → "with production of the song completeed Kennedy"
  • As "sizzling" is a quote, you need to put the reference here, even though it's in the Lead.
  • ""club" and "dancefloor-like" qualities", same here, reference(s) needed.

"Aharoni">Calvin ]]• TalkThatTalk 17:54, 16 November 2011 (UTC)Reply

  • → "by music critics,"
  • Instead of saying "The song" twice in the third para, change of them to "Disturbia".
  • → " then highest debut; the song peaked at number one on the chart, and stayed there for two consecutive weeks." Perhaps also state how many number one singles it gave Rihanna at the time?
  • → "was directed by Anthony Mandler" How many had he actually directed before "Disturbia" ?
  • → "gas chamber"
  • → "in a prison cell and gass chamber. Other scenes include Rihanna in a gas chamber," Why do you say gas chamber twice? Sort this line out then I will say what else is wrong with it, as it's confusing to you if I explain it now.
  • "The song has been a staple in Rihanna's performances" Makes no sense. I get what you are getting at, but it's not worded well.

Calvin • TalkThatTalk 16:12, 12 November 2011 (UTC)Reply

Will continue other sections a bit later. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 14:36, 15 November 2011 (UTC)Reply

Lead round two

edit

Change to:

"Disturbia" is a song by Barbadian recording artist Rihanna, taken from the re-release, Good Girl Gone Bad: Reloaded (2008), of her third studio album Good Girl Gone Bad (2007). The song was released as the third single from the reloaded edition of the album, and seventh overall. The song was written by Andre Merritt, Chris Brown, Brian Kennedy, Rob. A, with production of the song completed by Kennedy. "Disturbia" is an uptempo dance-pop and electro-pop song with a "sizzling" beat.[1][2] "Disturbia" was well received by music critics with many of them praising its dark musical tone, lyrics and beat.

"Disturbia" debuted at number eighteen in the US Billboard Hot 100 and became Rihanna's then highest debut. Later, it managed to reach number-one on the chart, and stayed there for two consecutive weeks. With that the song became Rihanna's third number-one single from Good Girl Gone Bad and fourth overall in the United States. The song also reached number one in Belgium (Flanders) and New Zealand and became a top-ten hit in more than twenty countries including Australia, Canada and the United Kingdom. The accompanying music video for "Disturbia" was directed by American director Anthony Mandler, and portrays Rihanna in various situations such as in a prison cell and gas chamber. "Disturbia" has regularly featured in Rihanna's tours and live performances since its release. The song was part of the set-list on her three major tours: Good Girl Gone Bad (2007—09), Last Girl on Earth (2010—11) and Loud Tour (2011).

A lot of it was waffle, the Lead was too long for the article, which isn't that long. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 16:53, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply

  Not done ... And also not planning to do. "Disturbia" is not nominated for FA as "Hard" which by the way is half from "Disturbia". I can cut something from the lead, but this what you wrote here is funny. — Tomica1111 • Question Existing? 17:39, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
Cut out the radio release, "It is reminiscent of one of Rihanna's previous singles "Don't Stop the Music". Lyrically, the song discusses the general experiences of anguish, anxiety and confusion.", the award it won and the grammy nomination (it's only a nomination, not a win). This is just padding it out. Make the Lead three paragraphs. And cut out the "List of Summer songs" and the About.com, it's pointless in the Lead. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 17:55, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
  Done by Jivesh — Tomica1111 • Question Existing? 18:14, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
(edit conflict) I don't want to see four paragraphs, it doesn't look right. Three would look a lot better. And it reads like a list of cold hard facts, the flow is awful. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 18:15, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
Welcome me warmly RiRi stans. Lol. Calvin, GAN =/= FAC. A four paragraph lead can remain for a song of the standard of "Disturbia". It was very successful, well received by critics, was nominated for awards, and was performed on numerous occasions. Jivesh 1205 (talk) 18:24, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
(edit conflict) It looks weak, and I stand by it read a like a list of hard facts, the flow is really bad. Three paragraphs would look a lot better. Love the Way You Lie has four, but they are bigger and more informationall. Disturbia is not Love the Way You Lie, nor was it as successful or does it have as much information. I'm standing my ground on this. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 18:26, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
Oh God, sometimes you really go on my nerves! What looks weak here please? I can tell you at least three Rihanna articles that have weaker leads than "Disturbia"... — Tomica1111 • Question Existing? 18:32, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
Three paragraphs would look a lot stronger than having four. I'm not saying the content is weak, however the are major flow issues. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 18:33, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
Jivesh has made it into three paragraphs, and it looks a lot better, but the flow is still a problem. (More so that before now). Calvin • TalkThatTalk 18:36, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
Re-write   Done Jivesh 1205 (talk) 18:38, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
"Jivesh has made it into three paragraphs, and it looks a lot better, but the flow is still a problem. (More so that before now)." Calvin • TalkThatTalk 18:39, 24 November 2011 (UTC)Reply
I've done this now. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 13:08, 25 November 2011 (UTC)Reply

Background

edit

Will start later today. Calvin • TalkThatTalk 13:08, 25 November 2011 (UTC)Reply

GA Pass

edit

All of my concerns have been addressed. As this is not a featured article review, any more concerns can be fixed later. This review has been going on for too long, and Calvin does not appear to be active in the discussion anymore. I strongly believe that this article currently meets the GA standard, and this should be acknowledged. Congratulations! Basilisk4u (talk) 23:50, 27 November 2011 (UTC)Reply

  1. ^ Cite error: The named reference Yahoo! Music was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
  2. ^ Cite error: The named reference Digital Spy was invoked but never defined (see the help page).
Add topic
Retrieved from "https://en.wikipedia.org/w/index.php?title=Talk:Disturbia_(song)/GA1&oldid=1142437812"