| Discussion Topic |
Replies (estimated) |
Archive Link
|
| Trivia |
2 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Trivia
|
| Place of Birth |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Place of Birth
|
| Character assasination |
5 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Character assasination
|
| More evidence needed |
3 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#More evidence needed
|
| Character assasination |
2 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Character assasination 2
|
| Vexatious litigant |
7 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Vexatious litigant
|
| 1421 theory |
4 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#1421 theory
|
| Primary sources |
17 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Primary sources
|
| Personal history section removed |
21 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Personal history section removed
|
| Where to from here? |
7 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Where to from here?
|
| Infobox |
2 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Infobox
|
| Neutrality Tag |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Neutrality Tag
|
| The major problem with this article |
6 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#The major problem with this article
|
| IP socking & pov editing |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#IP socking & pov editing
|
| Forthcoming book on Atlantis |
23 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Forthcoming book on Atlantis
|
| "unanimously discounted by professional historians" |
15 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#"unanimously discounted by professional historians"
|
| Book on Atlantis and WP:CRYSTAL |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Book on Atlantis and WP:CRYSTAL
|
| The Links to the 1421 and 1434 articles have been deleted by vandals who are trying to suppress this information from public |
5 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#The Links to the 1421 and 1434 articles have been deleted by vandals who are trying to suppress this information from public
|
| RFC regarding the recent merger |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#RFC regarding the recent merger
|
| SPA using at least 2 IP addresses and canvassing |
12 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#SPA using at least 2 IP addresses and canvassing
|
| Neutrality |
30 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Neutrality
|
| THE 1421 MAP |
7 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#THE 1421 MAP
|
| Map image displayed twice |
3 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Map image displayed twice
|
| Removed unnecessary statement |
12 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Removed unnecessary statement
|
| Fictional, Conspiracy category |
14 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Fictional, Conspiracy category
|
| Proof |
5 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Proof
|
| Reference lacks of neutrality |
5 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Reference lacks of neutrality
|
| Balanced and sourced facts |
20 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Balanced and sourced facts
|
| Too negative to be unbiased |
20 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Too negative to be unbiased
|
| "Menzies' theories are dismissed as fictitious" |
23 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#"Menzies' theories are dismissed as fictitious"
|
| Menzies' lack of command of Chinese |
33 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Menzies' lack of command of Chinese
|
| "vexatious litigant" |
37 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#"vexatious litigant"
|
| "scholarly failings" |
5 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#"scholarly failings"
|
| the Finlay quote is illogical |
13 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#the Finlay quote is illogical
|
| claims of "dramatic forthcoming evidence" |
8 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#claims of "dramatic forthcoming evidence"
|
| Couldn't resist...1859... |
3 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Couldn't resist...1859...
|
| map problems in the article |
9 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#map problems in the article
|
| "Menzies has academic supporters in China and in America" |
11 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#"Menzies has academic supporters in China and in America"
|
| "By his own account" |
8 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#"By his own account"
|
| Apply fringe standards |
7 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Apply fringe standards
|
| 23 March reversion |
6 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#23 March reversion
|
| The heroic transatlantic voyages of the Minoans |
3 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#The heroic transatlantic voyages of the Minoans
|
| Map section |
9 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Map section
|
| Reorganized material |
7 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 1#Reorganized material
|
| Biographical synopsis |
4 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Biographical synopsis
|
| "lacks supporting references for Chinese voyages beyond East Africa" |
7 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#"lacks supporting references for Chinese voyages beyond East Africa"
|
| Just curious |
10 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Just curious
|
| Lost Empire of Atlantis |
5 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Lost Empire of Atlantis
|
| Is this correct? |
2 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Is this correct?
|
| Original reserach in criticism sections |
10 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Original reserach in criticism sections
|
| Menzies claim that "Accepted New Zealand history" is that the Maori brought horses & went to the Americas |
4 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Menzies claim that "Accepted New Zealand history" is that the Maori brought horses & went to the Americas
|
| 1421 Hypothesis |
3 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#1421 Hypothesis
|
| Atttempt to remove the redirect at 1421: The Year China Discovered the World |
2 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Atttempt to remove the redirect at 1421: The Year China Discovered the World
|
| When did Taccola complete his treatise? |
14 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#When did Taccola complete his treatise?
|
| Recent IP edits |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Recent IP edits
|
| Video |
2 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Video
|
| Chinese discovery of America &c redirect here |
3 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Chinese discovery of America &c redirect here
|
| 1421 and 1434 |
8 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#1421 and 1434
|
| POV |
24 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#POV
|
| POV (cont.) |
34 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#POV (cont.)
|
| Pseudohistory |
42 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Pseudohistory
|
| Undue weight |
23 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Undue weight
|
| 1421: The Year China Discovered America |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#1421: The Year China Discovered America
|
| Another external link? |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Another external link?
|
| Chinese treasure ship |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Chinese treasure ship
|
| The book is "1421: The Year China Discovered the World", by Gavin Menzies, is not a serious book. |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#The book is "1421: The Year China Discovered the World", by Gavin Menzies, is not a serious book.
|
| Obligatory talk page discussion |
5 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Obligatory talk page discussion
|
| Seems to be an attack on the book |
7 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies#Seems to be an attack on the book
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#External links modified
|
| External links modified |
1 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#External links modified 2
|
| Gavin Menzies or Debunking a Book |
3 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies#Gavin Menzies or Debunking a Book
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 21 May 2018 |
4 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies/Archive 2#Semi-protected edit request on 21 May 2018
|
| Semi-protection request (25 July 2019) |
7 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies#Semi-protection request (25 July 2019)
|
| Semi-protected edit request on 1 September 2024 |
2 |
Talk:Gavin Menzies#Semi-protected edit request on 1 September 2024
|
