Talk:Hamline University/GA4

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Comments These are some preliminary comments that I can expand tomorrow

• I'm categorically opposed to rankings appearing in the lead as this is undue weight with regard to their importance as well as on any one organization's particular methodology
• The history section overall seems very strong.
• Image sizes need to be standardized rather than varying widely.
• List of master's degrees associated with individual schools in unencyclopedic and should be removed
• The academics and other sections are missing basic descriptive information available from the Carnegie Foundation, Chronicle of Higher Education, and Department of Education
• Partnership section is a bit of a WP:COATRACK in terms of discussing geographical locations (in a very POV manner) rather than the university or its programs. I believe the entire section could be summarized in a few sentences and merged into an Academics section
• Student life needs less about dining facilities and more about newspapers, radio/tv stations, notable student groups, student government
• The general structure of UNIGUIDE needs to be better-adhered to.
• An administration and organization section to discuss the board of trustees, senior administration, school organization, and faculty all needs to be included.

I hope this helps. Madcoverboy (talk) 05:14, 7 July 2009 (UTC)