Talk:Happy Refugees/GA1

GA Review

Reviewer: Carbrera (talk · contribs) 01:44, 31 March 2016 (UTC)

Hello, I am Carbrera, and I'll be reviewing this article for possible good article submission.

Full review coming very soon. Carbrera (talk) 01:44, 31 March 2016 (UTC)

Infobox

• Please provide an alternative description "alt" for the image of the band included
• You don't have to include a list for the past members, considering there is only one; please remove the bullet point

Lead

• The correct form of verb in this sentence is actually "is", not "are"
• Add "that" after "band from London,"
• Who are they considered to be one of the last bands of the DIY era by? Please clarify here to prevent confusion
• It's good that you include the information about comparisons here, but it should also be included below
• This section could easily warrant a second paragraph listing the group's accomplishments, releases, and awards (in any) here; please expand

History

1981-86: Formation and Last Chance Saloon

Paragraph 1

• No comma is necessary after "Hamburger Boy"
• Is the mention of The Colors Out of Time necessary since there is no article for it; if you find it necessary, please add a link to it so a future article may be warranted
• "Paul Johnston, came along to..." → "Paul Johnston joined them to..."

Paragraph 2

• This entire paragraph should be moved to the end of the first paragraph as it deals with what paragraph one is talking about

Paragraph 3

• I know what you mean, but you should clarify on what "four-piece" means
• If Warehouse Sound / Enshrined in a Memory is a single, it should be in quotation marks, not in italics
• Expand on "underground acclaim"

Paragraph 4

• This paragraph is good

2010-present: Rerelease and Beyond Moth and Rust

Paragraph 1

• "downloadable package" → "digital download"
• The rest of this entire section is quite good

Influence

• I believe this section should be retitled, perhaps something similar to "Influence and legacy"
• This section could be greatly expanded, could it?

Members

• Good! :)

Discography

• I would recommend creating articles for these albums; yes I know it's by far not required, but it would be beneficial to both you and Wikipedia! :)
• Include ";Studio albums" before listing them; but remove the quotation marks that I included in this example

References

• The reflist should be 'reflist|30em', not just 'reflist'

External links

• I don't see the need for the link to Gymnasium Records' Discogs page; remove, or explain why it should be included

End of GA Review:

This article needs quite a bit of expansion. I'm worried that this article isn't near being GA quality yet. I'm a bit worried about the notability of this subject, considering the minimal sources included in the article. If some expansion can be accomplished, I will definitely re-review the article, but as of now, some works needs to occur. Thank you. Carbrera (talk) 00:46, 1 April 2016 (UTC)

I am still relatively concerned with the notability of this subject; two days are left for changes to be made to this article. Thank you. Carbrera (talk) 01:29, 6 April 2016 (UTC)

Seven days have passed and I have noticed that the nominator hasn't edited for a few months; I'm afraid I'm going to fail this article. However, feel free to make the changes mentioned here and renominate it when you get the chance. Thank you! Carbrera (talk) 01:22, 8 April 2016 (UTC)