Talk:Josephine Amelia Perkins

Latest comment: 7 months ago by Johnpacklambert in topic Is this an article on history or a plot summary

Is this an article on history or a plot summary

edit

This article seems to treat as reliable and accurate the autobiographical writings of one person. It borders on plot summary. If this person is real and historical, we should treat her self written writings as primary. Wikipedia is not to be use primary sources. We need to better use secondary sources. We also need to question if those sources are treating her as real and historical, or just her works as interesting literature. If the later we need to avoid over using anything to make claims about actual historical events.John Pack Lambert (talk) 11:25, 27 March 2024 (UTC)Reply