Talk:Julie Hilden

Latest comment: 3 years ago by Matuko in topic Notability concerns

Notability concerns

edit

Hi, I came across this article through the link on the Stephen Glass article. I see that it was written by a founding Wikipedian, so I'm loath to nominate it for deletion through WP:AFD or WP:PROD, but I have concern about its notability.

When the article was created, Julie Hilden was beginning a career as a novelist and as an attorney, but she died in 2018, so her permanent notability may rest in the fact that she's the late wife of Stephen Glass, whose notability is undeniably permanent, so I think WP:INVALIDBIO applies here.

This article cites four sources, three of which are obituaries, and the fourth source is a archive of her legal commentary on FindLaw, so WP:RS may also be an issue. Her biographical details could easily be added to the Stephen Glass article, since the article content is identical to the cited obituaries, but I don't think she warrants a standalone article.

Any thoughts? Matuko (talk) 00:10, 26 September 2021 (UTC)Reply