Talk:Kiss & Cry (song)/GA1
Latest comment: 8 years ago by CaliforniaDreamsFan in topic GA Review
GA Review
editGA toolbox |
---|
Reviewing |
Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch
Reviewer: Carbrera (talk · contribs) 03:17, 2 June 2016 (UTC)
Infobox
edit- Everything looks good!
Lead
editParagraph 1
edit- Also looks good!
Paragraph 2
edit- Since this article seems to be written in American English, "favourable" should actually be "favorable"
Background and release
editParagraph 1
edit- I don't think you need to mention what each of the mixers and recorders are managed by; it seems pretty unnecessary to me
Paragraph 2
edit- Add "was" before "finally served as..."
- Rest looks great
Composition
editParagraph 1
edit- Fix "song "sound like"... (wrong tense here)
- "analysed" --> "analyzed"
- You can summarize and/or paraphrase some of these quotes so this section isn't so dependent on them
Paragraph 2
edit- Good
Critical response
edit- "labelling" --> "labeling"
- Please change to "Japanese music editor Random J highlighted it as one of the album's best tracks, praising it for being "funky" and "bouncy"."
Accolades and recognitions
edit- change title; "recognitions" isn't a word
- Once again, "recognitions" isn't a word
- "favourite" --> "favorite"
- Is 24/25 the lowest position? Or was the poll ranking the top 24 positions?
Commercial performance
editParagraph 1
edit- You use "chart week" and "charting weeks" quite frequently; you can change it up a bit if you please
- Remove "on the singles chart" in the second to last sentence
Paragraph 2
edit- "Billboard" needs to be italicized
- Good elsewhere
Music video and promotion
editParagraph 1
edit- Add the year to August 2 please
- Quote with Ref #38 needs to be a bit shorter; you can summarize/paraphrase it please
Paragraph 2
edit- Add the year to August 31 please
Chart and certifications
edit- Shouldn't the "Japan Yearly Chart" be placed in the "Year-end" format?
See also
edit- Put the first quotation mark around "Beautiful World"; you're missing it
External links
edit- Add a MetroLyrics link to the song's official lyrics using the template; see "Make Me Like You"'s external links section for example
- The only needed template here is "Utada Hikaru songs", not "Utada Hikaru" since the song is not linked in the template
End of GA Review:
editAnother good article, on hold for seven days; thanks! Carbrera (talk) 20:13, 2 June 2016 (UTC)
- @Carbrera: All done and dusted Regarding the recording part in the background section, I removed the mixing/editing part but left the studio recording in. CaliforniaDreamsFan (talk · contribs} 04:41, 3 June 2016 (UTC)