Talk:Kyar Ba Nyein

Untitled

I have took the facts and translated from the article written in Burmese by Ludu Daw Ah Mar Mandalaythu Mandalaytha mya or Mandalayans 1991 book,"Burmese Muslim Kyar Ba Nyein” chapter[1] While Googling I found a blog with some of the scans of the book about the Burmese boxers especially from Mandalay, including Kyar Ba Nyein. Mandalay 150 Anniversary Magazine, Shwebo Barmathi Aung Khin’s ,”Burmese famous boxers in the World Olympic Boxing Ring",page 430 [2], 431 [3]and 432[4] --Darz kkg (talk) 13:01, 28 December 2009 (UTC)

Although there are many issues with this article we all know that there is only ONE big issue with the Wikipedia editors or administrators.

See the multiple tags. He/She never understand Burmese language and even failed to think rationally. If do not understand, I am afraid he should just ask the help of many Burmese Wikipedians. Ludu Daw Amar was a vell known and respected journalist. She owned the Ludu newspaper. I hope all the Burmese Wiki editors know about Kyar Ba Nyein. He was the Burmese Boxing Champion represented the country even in Olympics and a Referee at the SEAP Game. He was the father of Burmese traditional boxing. I had not just given the name of two books but the scanned pages. I am fed up with this kind of editors. He should be BANNED for at least three months for this reckless action.--Darz kkg (talk) 14:21, 28 December 2009 (UTC)

The onus is on the editor to provide documentation and sources. Incorporate the sources you have found into the article. As it stands, there is much text yet no references for it. --Ari (talk) 06:17, 29 December 2009 (UTC)

I had already provided the sources, documentation and translation. But I have to admit that this article needs a lot of help from other editors to reach the Wiki standard.

Problem is you cound not understand those sources and documentation but still come in wrongly just to score some points. Finding falts on others is easy for all the people. As an experienced Wikipedian, why you failed to sign after your talk? Not only me, a lot of people are fed up with Wikipedia because of these kind of insults. You could search the news yourself. I am not giving you the citation or reference of that news.--Darz kkg (talk) 05:33, 29 December 2009 (UTC)

Talk pages are not forums. Keep your rants to yourself - or at least on topic. It is the onus of the editor to supply citations. Just because you refuse to is your problem. --Ari (talk) 06:17, 29 December 2009 (UTC)

Actually the book I mentioned is No. 14th. Mandalaythu Mandalaytha mya - Mandalayans 1991 mentioned in wiki biography of Ludu Daw Amar under the Publications section.

Because we translated from Burmese language, the wordings and spellings are sometimes accidently different. I will abide by the first stablished version in Wiki and change them later.

I am not refusing to give the references for this article but just referring to the International news report about people, especially the new commers, got their ego abrased and tried to stay away from Wiki. I am not in a position or mood to discuss about this in your talk page but decided to put this here so that I could prove that there is a legitimate concerns and issues about this article. It is meant to avoid deletion of this article indiscriminately. Alhough putting in warnings of possible blockage in my talk page is like aggressive and rude, I hereby offer a peace offer to you. I understand that it is just a very minor issue and misunderstanding. I hope we all would be able to work together to improve Wikipedia. --Darz kkg (talk) 08:32, 29 December 2009 (UTC)

I found back the book:*Mandalay 150th. Anniversary Magazine (Printed in May 2009 published by U Sein Shwe @ Sein Shwe Hlaing, Chief Editor Maung Hla Paw - Mandalay.) Shwebo Barmati Aung Khin’s ,”Burmese famous boxers in the World Olympic Boxing Ring". In this book we could read about where Kyar Ba Nyein's breif history including the story about his 'unfair' defeat in Helsinki Olympics due to alleged fault of referee and his photograph.

Myanmar Olympians in the official web-page of Myanmar Ministry of sports.[5]

Myanmar Olympians

Myanmar officially participated in the quadrennial Olympic Games since it’s independence in 1948, at the XIV Olympiad held in London.

XV Helsinki Olympic, Finland 1952. B. Thompson, Tiger Ba Nyein, Stanley Majid, San Hla (All boxing)(anyhow San Hla could not participated due to increased body weight), Tun Maung (Weightlifting), Kyaw Yin (Weightlifting).

Now I found the Wiki article about 1952 Summer Olympics boxing_

Featherweight (-57kg)

Gold	Ján Zachara  Czechoslovakia
Silver	Sergio Caprari  Italy
Bronze	Joseph Ventaja  France
Bronze	Leonard Leisching  South Africa

Winner	NOC	Result	Loser	NOC
First Round (July 28)
Sergio Caprari	Italy	BYE
Pentti Niinivuori	Finland	BYE
Lech Drogosz	Poland	3 - 0	Kyar Ba Nyein	Burma --Darz kkg (talk) 06:20, 30 December 2009 (UTC) I hereby give the reliable third party reference. The book is in English, and could read in scribd) U Razak of Burma, a Teacher, a Leader , a Martyr by Dr Nyi Nyi, BSC (Hons) Ph D (London) D.I.C. 1st. Edition July 2007, ISBN: 978 974 433 092 5. OS Printing House Co Ltd. Bangkok.Line 3,4&5, paragraph 5 page 9. Author is the Former Prof of Geology, Director of Universities, Permanent Secretary of Education, Deputy Minister of Education, Minister of Mines, Ambassador to Australia and New Zealand, Later UNICEF as Director of Programmes. After retirement, Clinical Prof of Public Health in Tulane School of Public Health and Tropical Medicine, and member of Board of Directors of several International non-profit organizations. [6]--Darz kkg (talk) 05:26, 6 January 2010 (UTC) May be it is the time to delete or remove most of the Admin Tags such as_ additional references or sources for verification. needs sources or references that appear in third-party publications. notability of this article's subject listed for deletion But I have to admit that this article needs the other editors' kind help to Wikify and improving is needed. --Darz kkg (talk) 05:38, 6 January 2010 (UTC) Another article in Mandalay 150th. Anniversary Magazine (Printed in May 2009 published by U Sein Shwe @ Sein Shwe Hlaing, Chief Editor Maung Hla Paw - Mandalay.) ,article of M.A. Ma Ohn about The Central National High School or No BEHS. About the school the boxng club and Mr Fisher.--Darz kkg (talk) 14:17, 8 January 2010 (UTC) Allow me to remove some tags which are out of date. No more multiple issues, not a living person, additional references or sources and third-party publications given, notability established, no reply nor objection to my request to remove tags for 10 days. If I am wrong and not authorized to remove them, please accept my sincere apology and feel free to put back all the tags. I would not touch the tags again.--Darz kkg (talk) 14:05, 16 January 2010 (UTC) File:Ba Nyein 10.jpg Nominated for Deletion An image used in this article, File:Ba Nyein 10.jpg, has been nominated for deletion at Wikimedia Commons in the following category: Deletion requests October 2011 What should I do? Don't panic; a discussion will now take place over on Commons about whether to remove the file. This gives you an opportunity to contest the deletion, although please review Commons guidelines before doing so. If the image is non-free then you may need to upload it to Wikipedia (Commons does not allow fair use) If the image isn't freely licensed and there is no fair use rationale then it cannot be uploaded or used. This notification is provided by a Bot --CommonsNotificationBot (talk) 15:39, 5 October 2011 (UTC) Sorry, now only I have seen this. The immages are FREE. These pics are sent to me by his son, U Win Nyein, a famous Journalist in Myanmar, on my request. He had even sent 5 pics but I just chosen the best only. He had give me to put in Wikipedia and is allowed to use freely in anyplace by anyone as long as not using to degrade his father. TQ Please kindly edit the usage license and put back in the article.--Darz kkg (talk) 07:02, 20 October 2012 (UTC)