Talk:List of ancient Greek cities
This is the talk page for discussing improvements to the List of ancient Greek cities article. This is not a forum for general discussion of the article's subject. |
Article policies
|
Find sources: Google (books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL |
This article is rated List-class on Wikipedia's content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
It is requested that a map or maps be included in this article to improve its quality. Wikipedians in Greece may be able to help! |
Mistitled in an inept way
editMost of the places on this list were not (and never have been) cities. They were merely villages, towns, (or even hamlets). A much more honest and correct title would be
List of ancient Greek cities, towns, and villages —Preceding unsigned comment added by 98.81.6.61 (talk) 14:59, 13 September 2010 (UTC)
- This is an interesting point. The term city is a representation of ancient Greek polis, the city-state. Every village belonged to a polis, no matter how small. Sometimes we use city-state. Of course our city does not in any way resemble the polis, and if we lived then we would't call them cities. But how are we to translate polis? There is an unbridgeable cultural disconnect. The long-standing convention is to call every polis a city. It is not a dishonety. Rather, city in this context necessarily means something else. The convention is understood in the classics game.Botteville (talk) 14:41, 24 October 2018 (UTC)
- We should call them city-states, or simply poleis, since there is already an article on them... The list is indeed deeply flawed as it contains many settlements that were not poleis, and belong to other eras (such as Minoan settlements). I am preparing a revision of the list, that would only contain poleis and be organised geographically. You can see an excerpt on the Magna Graecia article: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Magna_Graecia#List_of_Hellenic_Poleis_in_Italy T8612 (talk) 14:57, 24 October 2018 (UTC)
Scope
editWhat is considered "Ancient", what is considered "Greek" and what is considered "a city"? All of these things affect the scope of this list. For example, Knossos was a center of Minoan culture but I am not sure about later Greek inhabitation. Are Minoan centers considered Greek? What about Mycenaean? Mycenae itself was inhabited by a small population at least until the Persian wars. What is the cutoff date for "Ancient"?
- Ho, ho, ho. Your grandfather is an ancient.Seriously, there is no unambiguous meaning of ancient. It is opposed to modern. I suppose ancient leaves off where mediaeval begins. Classicists have no problem with it.Botteville (talk) 14:50, 24 October 2018 (UTC)
What about Alexander? Since he captured Babylon, should that be considered a "Greek" city?
Delphi was an important sactuary, but was not really a city. Is the Piraeus consided a city separate from Athens?
Using the greek term of "polis" may be slightly less ambiguous for this article.
Also, since this is a list of Greek cities, the ancient Greek names should probably be used when possible.
Possibilities:
Organize list by modern country
Organize list by mother city (for colonies)
Unless I am greatly misinformed, there were never any Greek cities in Japan. Especially the ancient kind. Unless somebody shows some evidence I am going to revert that last edit.--SkiDragon 20:09, 28 February 2007 (UTC)
Please explain to my how Macedon could possibly be considered a "city". Especially a "Greek city".--SkiDragon 06:49, 2 May 2007 (UTC)
- Also, what qualifies as a "city"? Delphi was the site of an oracle, a religious site, not a city in the usual sense. Some islands are included; how do these qualify? Surely Delos was not a normal settlement? I do not argue against inclusion, although a universal list of ancient Greek sites would lack focus, but the scope needs to be understood. Folks at 137 (talk) 08:51, 8 March 2009 (UTC)
Cities/definition: City should be in this context, the urban center, from village size to large urban metropolis(in the old days); though Delphi/Delphos is mostly a sanctuary in Classical Antiquity it would have a very small population in or around, during those centuries when it held the prophecy temple; there was also a theatre which attests to a population coming to the temple-complex or staying for a while; I think there should not be any doubt that ancient peoples/tribes/ethnic groups that dwelt in cities (like Mycenae) became in the VIII century b.C. the Hellenes, the classical Greeks and eventually the modern Greeks, and so their cities are cities of the greek civilization.GFlusitania (talk) 23:54, 13 August 2009 (UTC)
There are other Greek cities (founded by Greeks) including Massalia>Marsailles and Kalais>Calais in France, Emporio in Spain, The Pillars of Hercules>The Straights of Gibraltar in Portugal, there are numerous cities in modern Italy, including, Neapolis>Naples, Sybaris, Syracuse, Poseidonia>Paestum, etc.
What about a page including the following: MYTHOLOGY IN MODERN SOCIETY
PLACES IN THE UNITED STATES NAMED FROM MYTHOLOGY
- No, NOT from mythology, because most of the places listed below were/are actual places. Also, in particular, Troy was not a mythological place, and archaeological diggings have shown that Troy was a real place in Asia Minor.98.81.6.61 (talk) 15:04, 13 September 2010 (UTC)
Mythology is everywhere! There are hundreds of places in the United States (and Canada, not to mention the entire world!) named from Greek Mythology. Odds are you'll find a few good examples right in your own state, wherever you live.
Consider that there are at least 16 cities named Athens in the United States! Or, even more amazing, there exist no less than 26 American cities that contain Troy in their names!
I've researched each of the 50 States and have put together a huge list of American cities whose names relate to mythology. Let me know if I've missed any and I'll be happy to add them.
Athens, the capital city of Greece, is named after the goddess Athena:
Athens, Georgia
Athens, Ohio
Athens, Alabama
Athens, Indiana
Athens, Maine
Athens, New York
Athens, Pennsylvania
Athens, Tennessee
Athens, Texas
Athens, West Virginia
Athens, Wisconsin
Athens, Louisiana
Athens, Michigan
Athens, Illinois
Athens, Pennsylvania
New Athens, Illinois
Athens County, Ohio
Athens, Wisconsin
Attica, New York
Athena's Roman equivalent was Minerva:
Minerva, Kentucky
Minerva, New York
Minerva, Ohio
Achilles was the greatest warrior of the Trojan War, killed only when an arrow struck his heel, the only vulnerable spot on his body:
Achille, Oklahoma (a reader mentioned that this is a Native American derivation, not Greek)
Achilles, Virginia
Ajax was the name of two famous warriors of the Trojan War:
Ajax, South Dakota
Apollo was another Olympian, the god of music and light. After him is named:
Apollo, Pennsylvania
North Apollo, Pennsylvania
Apollo Beach, Florida
Apollo Annex, Florida
Apollo Theater, Chicago
Apollo Theater, New York
Amazons in Greek mythology were a ferocious race of warrior women:
Amazonia, Missouri
Arcadia was a famous place in ancient Greece:
Arcadia, California
Arcadia, Florida
Arcadia, Indiana
Arcadia, Iowa
Arcadia, Kansas
Arcadia, Louisiana
Arcadia, Michigan
Arcadia, Missouri
Arcadia, Nebraska
Arcadia, Pennsylvania
Arcadia, South Carolina
Arcadia, Wisconsin
Ares was one of the 12 Olympians, the despised god of war:
Ares Peak, New Mexico
Argo was the name of the famous ship that Jason and the Argonauts used to sail on their voyage to get the Golden Fleece.
Argo, Texas
Argos was the hundred-eyed watchman of Hera, slain by the Greek messenger god Hermes:
Argos, Indiana
Arion was the poet tossed overboard by Pirates who was saved by a dolphin:
Arion, Iowa Arion, Ohio
Atlas was the hapless Titan who was doomed to support the heavens on his shoulder forever. Many variations of his name have given us a number of American place names:
Atlantic Beach, Florida
Atlanta, Georgia
Atlanta, Idaho
Atlanta, Illinois
Atlanta, Indiana
Atlantic, Iowa
Atlanta, Kansas
Atlas, Kansas
Atlanta, Louisiana
Atlanta, Michigan
Atlas, Michigan
Atlanta, Missouri
Atlanta, Nebraska
Atlantic City, New Jersey
Atlanta, New York
Atlantic Beach, New York
Atlantic, North Carolina
Atlantic Beach, North Carolina
Atlantic, Pennsylvania
Atlasburg, Pennsylvania
Atlanta, Texas
Atlantic, Virginia
Aurora was the Roman goddess of the dawn, similar to the Greek Eos:
Aurora, Colorado
Aurora, Illinois
Aurora, Indiana
Aurora, Iowa
Aurora, Kansas
Aurora, Kentucky
Aurora, Maine
Aurora, Minnesota
Aurora, Missouri
Aurora, Nebraska
Aurora, New York
East Aurora, New York
Aurora, North Carolina
Aurora, Ohio
Aurora, Oregon
Aurora, South Dakota
Aurora, Utah
Aurora, West Virginia
Daphne was a beautiful woman who was pursued by the god Apollo. She turned into a laurel tree in order to escape from his amorous advances. After her is named:
Daphne, Alabama
Castor and Polux were famous twins of Greek mythology:
Castor, Louisiana
The Nymph Calypso was a witch who tried to convince the hero Odysseus to stay with her on her island, rather than sailing home:
Calypso, North Carolina
Cassandra was the seer who was cursed by Apollo, so that her prophecies were never believed:
Cassandra, Pennsylvania
Ceres was the Roman goddess of the harvest, similar to the Greek goddess Demeter:
Ceres, California
Ceres, Virginia
Clio was one of the nine Muses of Greek mythology:
Clio, Alabama
Clio, California
Clyo, Georgia
Clio, Iowa
Clio, Michigan
Clio, South Carolina
Clio, West Virginia
Corinth was a famous place in Greek mythology, figuring in numerous myths:
Corinth, Kentucky
Corinth, Mississippi
Corinth, New York
Corinth, Texas
Corinth, Vermont
East Corinth, Vermont
Crete was the island where Zeus was raised as a baby while hiding from the wrath of his father, Cronus:
Crete, Illinois
Crete, Nebraska
Diana was the Roman name for the Greek Artemis, goddess of the forest and the hunt:
Diana, Texas
Diana, West Virginia
Fortuna was the Roman goddess of luck, similar to the Greek Tyche:
Fortuna Ledge, Alaska
Fortuna, California
Fortuna, Missouri
The Oracles in mythology were respected seers who foretold the future:
Oracle, Arizona
The most famous Oracle was Apollo's, at a place called Delphi:
Delphi, Indiana
Delphia, Kentucky
Delphi Falls, New York
Hector was a brave warrior who fought on the Trojan side against the Greeks during the Trojan War. He was killed by Achilles:
Hector, Arkansas
Hector, California
Hector, New York
Homer was the ancient poet and writer who gave us the famous books the Iliad and the Odyssey:
Homer, Alaska
Homer, Georgia
Homerville, Georgia
Homer, Illinois
Homer, Indiana
Homer, Louisiana
Homer, Nebraska
Homer, New York
East Homer, New York
Homer, Ohio
Homerville, Ohio
Hymera was the Greek personification of the Day:
Hymera, Indiana
Hesperia was the Greek goddess who personified the Evening:
Hesperia, California
Hesperus was the elusive god who personified the Evening:
Hesperus, Colorado
Irene was the ancient Greek personification of Peace:
Irene, South Dakota
Irene, Texas
Iris was the Greek goddess of the Rainbow:
Iris, South Carolina
Ithaca was the island home of the Trojan War hero, Odysseus; the Odyssey by Homer detailed his voyage back home to Ithaca:
Ithaca, Nebraska
Ithaca, New York
Ithaca College, New York
Ithaca, Ohio
The Parthenon in Athens was the splendid temple at the Acropolis, built in honor of the great goddess Athena:
Parthenon, Arkansas
Dike (or Dyke, pronounced DEE-key) was the Greek mythological personification of Justice:
Dike, Iowa
Dike, Texas
Dyke, Virginia
Echo was the beautiful maiden who fell in love with the vain Narcissus and was reduced to just an echo:
Echo Lake, California
Echo, Louisiana
Echo, Minnesota
Echo, Oregon
Echo, Texas
Echo, Utah
The Elysian Fields was the final resting place of famous heroes:
Elysian, Minnesota
Elysian Fields, Texas
Eros was the Greek god of love, similar to the mischievous Roman Cupid:
Eros, Louisiana
Eros, Arizona
Flora was the Roman name for the Greek Chloris, goddess of plants and vegetation:
Flora, Illinois
Flora, Indiana
Flora, Louisiana
Flora, Mississippi
Glen Flora, Texas
Glen Flora, Wisconsin
The Griffin was a mythical creature with the face, beak, talons and wings of an eagle and the body of a lion:
Griffin, Georgia
Griffin, Indiana
Hades was the feared god of the Underworld:
Hades Creek, Washington
Hercules (Heracles) was the greatest hero of ancient Greece. He performed the famous 12 labors:
Hercules, California
Luna was the Roman goddess of the moon, equivalent to the Greek goddess Selene:
Luna, New Mexico
The city of Marathon was the setting for a magnificent battle, and where we get the modern day race called the marathon:
Marathon, New York
Mars was the Roman god of war, the equivalent of the Greek god Ares:
Mars Hill, Maine
Mars, Pennsylvania
Medusa was the monster who would turn to stone whomever happened to look upon her:
Medusa, New York
Mentor was a famous tutor/teacher in ancient Greek mythology:
Mentor, Minnesota
Mentor, Ohio
Mercury was the Roman name for the Greek god Hermes, winged messenger to the gods:
Mercury, Nevada
Mount Olympus was the lofty home of the ancient gods. From Olympus we get place names such as:
Olympic Valley, California
Olympia Heights, Florida
Olympia Fields, Illinois
Olympia, Kentucky
East Olympia, Virginia
Olympia, Washington
The nine Muses in Greek mythology were the ones who inspired the arts, sciences, music and all things cultural:
Muse, Pennsylvania
Neptune was the Roman name for Poseidon, Greek god of the sea:
Neptune Beach, Florida
Neptune, New Jersey
Neptune City, New Jersey
Orestes was the tragic figure who killed his mother, Clytaemnestra, and was pursued by the Furies, in the tragedy Oresteia by Aeschylus:
Orestes, Indiana
Pandora (all-gifted) was the first mortal woman. Her curiosity made her open up a jar (box), which unleashed all the world's evils upon the earth:
Pandora, Ohio
Pandora, Texas
Paris was the Trojan prince who ran away with beautiful Helen, an act which caused the famous Trojan War:
Paris, Tennessee
Paris, Texas
Penelope was the faithful wife to Odysseus, of Trojan War and Odyssey fame:
Penelope, Texas
Sparta was a famous city state in ancient Greece, renowned for its highly disciplined and ferocious warriors:
Sparta, Georgia
Sparta, Illinois
Sparta, Kentucky
Sparta, Michigan
Sparta, Mississippi
Sparta, New Jersey
Sparta, New York
East Sparta, Ohio
Sparta, Tennessee
Sparta, Virginia
Sparta, Wisconsin
Thebes was another famous city state, with a storied mythical history:
Thebes, Illinois
Troy was the ancient mythological city where the famous Trojan War took place. Many US places are named Troy:
Troy, Alabama
Troy, Idaho
Troy, Illinois
Troy Grove, Illinois
Troy, Indiana
Troy Mills, Iowa
Troy, Kansas
Troy, Maine
Troy, Michigan
New Troy, Michigan
Troy, Missouri
Troy, Montana
Troy, New Hampshire
Troy, New York
Troy, North Carolina
Troy, Ohio
Troy, Pennsylvania
Troy, South Carolina
Troy, Tennessee
Troy, Texas
Troy, Vermont
North Troy, Vermont
Troy, Virginia
Troy, West Virginia
East Troy, Wisconsin
Venus was the Roman name for gorgeous Aphrodite, Greek goddess of Love:
Venus, Florida
Venus, Pennsylvania
Venus, Texas
Vesta was the Roman name for the Greek goddess Hestia, ancient goddess of the home and hearth. Her attendants were called the Vestal virgins:
Vesta, Minnesota
Vesta, Virginia
Vestal, New York
Victoria was Roman for the Greek Nike, winged goddess of Victory:
Victoria, Minnesota
Victoria, Mississippi
Victoria, Texas
Victoria, Virginia
Vulcan was the Roman name for Hephaestus, Greek god of the forge:
Vulcan, Michigan
Vulcan, Missouri
Vulcan, West Virginia
Zephyr was one of the wind gods, the West Wind:
Zephyrhills, Florida
Zephyr Cove, Nevada
Zephyr, Texas
Notus was another wind god, this one the South Wind:
Notus, Idaho
Orion was a giant in Greek mythology who was placed in the stars as the Constellation Orion:
Orion, Illinois
Orion, Michigan
Juno was the Roman name for Hera, wife to Zeus, the supreme Greek Olympian:
Juno Beach, Florida
Jupiter was the Roman name for the King of the Olympians, Zeus:
Jupiter, Florida
Helen of Troy was the most beautiful woman on earth, and the cause of the Trojan War:
Lake Helen, Florida
Helen, Georgia
Helena, Georgia
Helen, Maryland
Helena, Missouri
Helena, Montana
Helena, New York
Helena, Oklahoma
Helen, West Virginia
Helenville, Wisconsin
Marathon was another famous Greek place and the scene of a decisive ancient battle. We get the modern 26 kilometer Marathon Race from this city:
Marathon, Florida
Marathon Shores, Florida
Marathon, Iowa
Marathon, Texas
Marathon, Wisconsin
The Phoenix was the legendary bird that would perish every few hundred years, only to be reborn from the ashes:
Phoenix, Arizona
Phoenix, Maryland
Phoenix, New York
Phoenix, Oregon
Phoenixville, Pennsylvania
Phenix, Virginia
Ulysses was the Roman name for Odysseus, hero of Homer's epic saga The Odyssey:
Ulysses, Kansas
Ulysses, Kentucky
Ulysses, Nebraska
Ulysses, Pennsylvania
Urania was the one of the nine Muses, the Greek Muse of astronomy, astrology and Universal love.
Urania, Louisiana
Uranus (Sky) was an original Titan, husband to Gaea (Mother Earth):
Uranus, Alaska
CHECK OUT THE STATES TRIVIA PAGE!
(includes a mythological city for each State)
[back to modern allusions] [homework help]
Web, myth narration & graphics created & maintained by Nick Pontikis Copyright © 1995 - 2010 Thanasi's Olympus Greek Restaurant The Myth Man persona © 1988 Nick Pontikis —Preceding unsigned comment added by 115.131.3.3 (talk) 08:55, 25 July 2010 (UTC)
- Well, this is very interesting but I don't know why you put it here. If it is your copyright it can't go on WP, and if you donate it to WP you can't put it here as it is off-topic.Botteville (talk) 14:54, 24 October 2018 (UTC)
Hellenese not "Greeks"
edit"Greek" is a derogatory term NEVER used in ancient Hellas, not even officially today (see Hellenic Republic. What are today (outside of modern Hellas) called "the ancient Greeks" were Hellenistic tribes who shared a common language and cultural ties. --Nikoz78 (talk) 01:48, 22 September 2010 (UTC)
- Your native culture is obviously not English so I will help you out here lest you think you can out-English the English. Hellenese is a neologism you just coined. It is not in general use, so we can't use it. Greek comes from Latin Graeci and has been in English for centuries. The only people I ever saw take offense at it were some not-really-anglicized immigrants from Greece who felt isolated in some prejudicial contexts. And there are those nasty jokes about the Greek wedding. My advice is not to identify with gutter English but hold yourself better than that. If you don't see any problem, most likely there will not be one. Accents are fine in America anyway. We like accents - something new and interesting in the hinterland. You can't use Hellenistic, either. The term is reserved in history for the period of Alexander and after until the Romans. Hellenes is good - the native ancient Greek term for themselves. But in non-scholarly English you would not be understood. The who? I would say, don't tell us what to say, instead find out what we say and accept it. There are of course some exceptions.Botteville (talk) 15:13, 24 October 2018 (UTC)
The question of inclusion
editThis is obviously a matter of judgement. Apparently if a settlement once spoke Greek then it is in, even though it may not have spoken it long and even though it may have been far from Greece. I'm having more of a problem with Akrotiri, which probably never spoke Greek at any period. The site is now part of Hellas however. What do you think?Botteville (talk) 15:19, 24 October 2018 (UTC)
- In case you were talking to me, I will only add the cities listed in the Inventory of Archaic and Classical Poleis by Mogens Herman Hansen. There should be separate lists for ancient Minoan and Mycenaean settlements. You cannot mix different civilisations together. T8612 (talk) 16:11, 24 October 2018 (UTC)
Unexaplained tagging
editThere is no need for tagging this list as soon as the correspodent articles are fine and sourced.Alexikoua (talk) 17:49, 28 October 2020 (UTC)
- The main problem of this article is that its scope is not clearly defined. T8612 (talk) 19:06, 28 October 2020 (UTC)