Talk:Lonsdale Belt/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Kosack (talk · contribs) 20:08, 28 June 2018 (UTC)

Will take a look at this, will post review in the next day or so. Kosack (talk) 20:08, 28 June 2018 (UTC)

Thank you. Just in the process of completing the outright winners section. been away working recently. Okeeffemarc (talk) 23:44, 30 June 2018 (UTC)

Here's my initial review

Lead

• I think the opening may need rewording slightly. If Lord Lonsdale Challenge Belt is the official title, then open with that. I would say "The Lord Lonsdale Challenge Belt, commonly known as the Lonsdale Belt, ..." would be more suitable. The Challenge Belt title can be mentioned further on.  Done
• In at the start of the final sentence needs a capital letter.  Done
• Could the lead be expanded? Brief mentions of  longest reigning, most reigns, first champion, etc.  Done (added a brief couple of sentences, wary of repeating myself too much in the article, please advise if you feel it needs more)

The National Sporting Club

• Link Lord Lonsdale to the relevant person.  Done
• Should champion be capitalised? Not in this context, so corrected
• Final sentence of the first paragraph is unsourced.  Done
• "the NSC British Lightweight title 8 November 1909" insert on before the date.  Done

First holders of NSC Challenge belts

• Insert a space between each flag and the name of the fighter, looks a bit squashed together at the moment. Done

First holders of the B.B.B.of.C. Lonsdale belt

• Again, use a space between fighter and flag for this table and the current holders table below. Done

Changes

• Excerpt doesn't need to be capitalised. Done

Theft

• "Bobby Vanzie Come home to Bradford" , sentence needa rewording. Done
• In McAteer's entry, sons > son's. Done

Outright winner

• Capitalise Lonsdale in the image caption. Done
• Is unnecessary capitalised in the first sentence. Done

2 time outright winners of Lonsdale Belt

• Spacing between fighter and flag in table and table below. Done

See Also

• Bettinson, Boxing Board of Control and National Sporting Club are all linked in the article so don't need to be included here. Done
• Is there a more centralised list or overview page of British boxing champions rather than having so many pages linked? Have taken them out of the section, as they are already in the Nav Section at the bottom of the page.

References

• Refs 1, 16has author - John Harding, 21 Done, 24No author cited by the BBC, but it is a reputable source, 27 BoxRec don't publish source names but is the official professional boxing record keeper, 28 Done, 32No Author cited but reputable news source, 33 Done, 37 Done, 43 Done, 44 Done, 47No Author cited but reputable news source, 55 Done, 62 Done, 66 Done, 83 Done, 86 Done, 98 Done, 99 Done, 100 Done, 114 Done, 118 Done, 129 Done,  133 Done, 134, 138, 141, 144, 145, 149, 152 and 153 need an author. - All  Done
• In Ref 6, I'm assuming Welsh and Summers are surnames so they would need capital letters.  Done
• Can we find an ISBN for ref 9? 9 is a BoxRec Record. 10 doesn't have an ISBN due to it's age
• Avoid using all capitals as in refs 29, 73, 113, 115, 122, 128, 143, even if the reference does the same, per WP:ALLCAPS. all  Done
• Ref 34 is a dead link. works for me, goes straight to the website. Can find an alternative if you still can't access
• Ref 35 needs an access date.  Done
• Ref 38, Ilford Recorder is the name of the paper, so Recorder needs a capital letter. Done
• Same for Wales Online in ref 44, Telegraph in ref 77 and Liverpool Echo in ref 93.  Done
• Ref 53 uses a different format accessdate to all other refs, maintain one style for consistency. Done
• Ref 85 has a broken link for the publisher. Done
• The Free Library in ref 108 is only a recreation of material originally published in the Coventry Evening Telegraph. So the Telegraph needs to be listed as the publisher and the Free Library included with the via= field. Done

Sorry it took slightly longer than I expected. Placed on hold. Kosack (talk) 08:05, 1 July 2018 (UTC)

Reply

Good afternoon @Kosack:, no worries, thanks for taking the time to give it all a thorough look. I have amended your post ticking off or commenting on your corrections. Please let me know what you think.

Kind regards, Okeeffemarc (talk) 20:04, 2 July 2018 (UTC)

Follow up review

Origin

• Should original be capitalised in the image caption? No so have changed
• "A total of 22 Lonsdale belts were issued by the NSC, and of these 20 were won outright.", need a ref for this sentence as it's the end of the paragraph.  Done

Outright winners of Lonsdale Belt

• I went to correct Charlie Magri and Carl Johansson's entries as they used lower case for the fighters name but noticed that you were deliberately piping the link to that. Is there a reason for that? No just missed that! Lots of data entry gives you snow blindness. Corrected now.

References

• Ref 35 (from SuperSport.com) is the dead link, either a ref was added in between the review or I wrote down the wrong one. Does it work for you? No, they must have ditched the article. have replaced with another source.

@Okeeffemarc: Nice work with the fixes, just a couple of minor issues above and I think this one will be ready for promotion. Kosack (talk) 12:29, 3 July 2018 (UTC)

Reply

@Kosack: All done. Thanks very much Okeeffemarc (talk) 15:00, 3 July 2018 (UTC)

@Okeeffemarc: A nice piece of work that meets the required GA criteria in my opinion, promoting. Kosack (talk) 15:51, 3 July 2018 (UTC)