Talk:Looj

Latest comment: 8 years ago by A Nebraska Cornhusker in topic Possible merge with iRobot page?

Criticism section

edit

Seems to be poorly reviewed and not a robot at all. Perhaps add a crit section? Turkeyphant 14:37, 1 January 2011 (UTC)Reply

Possible merge with iRobot page?

edit

The Looj section on the iRobot page is just one sentence long, but I believe that some information can be taken from this page and added to the iRobot page. However, a significant amount of information on this page is blatantly unencyclopedic. Information such as all of the model numbers, dimensions of the robot and that the battery must be removed before charging are completely unnecessary to a reader of wikipedia and if someone really needs to find the specific dimensions of the Looj robot, they can find it elsewhere on specialist sites. Common sense must be applied with regard to the level of detail to be included. This makes the whole page seem like an advertisement or an owners manual rather than an article, especially since the Looj has recieved generally unfavorable reviews and only a positive review is mentioned in "critical reception". Moreover, the information listed is not properly sourced. I am also concerned that the Looj robot is not that notable to have its own article with such a high degree of detail and a mention on the iRobot page is sufficent.

I am not trying to shame this article, but I do believe that it has serious issues. Please let me know what you think. I will be adding info to the iRobot page and may then nominate the page for deletion.A Nebraska Cornhusker (talk) 19:00, 27 May 2016 (UTC)Reply