Talk:Meir Har-Zion

Latest comment: 7 years ago by Padres Hana in topic Reference

Untitled

edit

Whilst the facts of this article may for all I know be true, they are written in what reads to me a distinctly anti-Sharon way, leading me to suspect that they are not written from a neutral point of view. Logically we should at least hear from the Sharon camp? Or is it indisputable that Meir Har-Zion is the Israeli Rambo, and Sharon a surrender monkey?

The article is basically crap and will be replaced by a proper biography when I get the time (or someone else does). --Zero 10:45, 16 May 2004 (UTC)Reply

Reference

edit

I moved this quote below off the main article. While the quote describes may him, it doesn't give any situational background or explains why. It may or may not be mis-representative of him. Need more information. "laconically killing Arab soldiers, peasants, and townspeople in a kind of fury without hatred." [1] Elon, The Israeli Founders, Fathers and Sons, P241

Morris gives this quote referenced to Elon p.234. I will check in due course. Padres Hana (talk) 11:15, 22 February 2017 (UTC)Reply

Over-exaggeration

edit

Anyone else think this article is a little fluffed up? A "military commando" but only served 3 years! Not to mention the toothpick arms. This guy's a clear-cut REMF. 24.190.209.14 (talk) 04:21, 5 December 2012 (UTC)Reply