Talk:Michigan State University School of Hospitality Business

Latest comment: 9 years ago by 75.108.94.227 in topic October 2010

October 2010

edit

I have removed the list of alumni, since none of them had either wiki articles or references to reliable sources to back up the claims made. Notable alumni can be added if one of those two conditions are met, but a link to a school website would not suffice. Drmies (talk) 19:49, 18 October 2010 (UTC)Reply

Alumni

edit

There are over 9,000 active alumni of the school in nearly every segment of the industry. Notable alumni include:

References

Update in 2015: I have wikilinked the names above, but note, just because the name is a bluelink, does not mean it DEFINITELY should be added back into the article, please first check that it is the same person that went to MSU, see WP:DBTF. Similarly, just because a name shows up as a redlink, does NOT definitely mean there is not a wikipedia article about the person... it might be under their legal name, or use their middle initial, or similar issues. Finally, see WP:NOTEWORTHY, it is fine to have people listed in mainspace under this article, if they are mentioned -- specifically as being graduates of this specific school -- in a newspaper article or television newscast (not the school newspaper... not the school's station... independent third-party notice), see WP:SOURCES. However, some articles ... usually university alumni subsections ... use a more stringent standard than WP:NOTEWORTHY, see WP:CSC for details. In the meantime, feel free to add names of known prominent alums to the list above, here on the talkpage; as time goes by, and more sources are collected, eventually the bluelink'd names will be moved back into the article proper. 75.108.94.227 (talk) 21:01, 18 August 2015 (UTC)Reply



university rankings versus other schools

edit

In the Faculty section of this article, there's a reference and link to Cornell University School of Hotel Administration without any citation to the report referenced.

Without proper citation, that reference to a competitor should be removed.

Thanks! (( above message added 14:45, 12 August 2015‎ , by User:90milesnorth ))

I'm wondering if the whole paragraph should be removed? The journal article I could find at removed per DMCA and WP:COPYVIO shows different statistics than the Wiki article shows, no? Ron Schnell 19:23, 17 August 2015 (UTC)Reply
I'm working on this too, oddly enough.  :-)     Some of the material is challenged-or-likely-to-be-challenged, but most of it is 'okay' by wiki-policy standards. I'm adding the link to teh competition where it belongs, in the see-also section. p.s. JHTR is paywall territory, that arizona link was likely an unauthorized upload by a student. See the section of Penn State University where they list JHTR rankings, with no hyperlinks. The rankings are skewed towards schools that list a ton of co-authors on every paper; MSU got 9th place overall in the 2009 study you linked to, but there was an updated study later, and they moved up in the rankings to beat out Cornell. Wikipedia should list (and explain the meaning of the esoteric ranking-scheme to our readership) not just the #9 ranking in the 2002-2006 era, but also (once it can be properly sources) the #1 ranking in a later update. 75.108.94.227 (talk) 20:05, 18 August 2015 (UTC)Reply