Talk:N-Acetylglutamate synthase

several confusing points:

1- in bacteria NAG is produced from OAT enzyme, at earlier place you said that: "NAG can be used in the production of ornithine and arginine" so I conclude that OAT help producing both ornithine and arginine, but OAT have defined as an enzyme in (cyclic ornithine production pathway) only and didn't mention it as also produce arginine.

2- as said above: in bacteria OAT synthesize NAG so NAGS act as supplementary, (then you said) In some plants and bacteria, however, NAGS catalyzes the first step in a ‘linear’ arginine production pathway. we conclude that the latter arginine synthesis do not happens through NAG (otherwise it will also act as NAG supplement and not contrast with it). "just to ascertain this"

3- (the role of arginine as an inhibitor of NAG in ornithine and arginine synthesis) didn't say if it is for vertebrates or bacteria: if for vertebrates: a contradiction happens because we know that arginine act as effector for NAGS in vertebrates: (L-arginine acts as an inhibitor in plant and bacterial NAGS "but an effector in vertebrates.") unlikely that it stimulate NAGS but inhibit overall NAG (at least such paradox have never been mentioned) and if it was for bacteria: then the mechanism would be missing: because although in bacteria arginine inhibit NAGS, but we knew that it is not NAGS that carry out NAG synthesis in bacteria, but it is OAT (NAGS act supplementary or in arginine linear pathway) so we should find something else: like if arginine inhibit OAT also, or some direct inactivation of NAG....

apart from these points (that mostly due to the many articles that antagonize each other), the article is wonderful and I thank whoever edited it.

Yasir muhammed ali (talk) 05:28, 12 April 2016 (UTC)