Talk:Nosso Lar

References???

References without value. History without value: One médium, a unique spirit without the same information by others mediums or other spirits. Books, films, theaters, television... Doc Elisa ^✉ 19:15, 9 March 2024 (UTC)

According to Allan Kardec, for information to be true it has to be validated by different mediums in different countries and transmitted by different spirits. This and all the books that follow, psychographed by Chico Xavier through the spirit of André Luís, there is no other medium on this planet who tells similar stories like Messengers, Liberation, etc. There is a lot of publicity, films, plays, audio books, 50 million books, royalties for the Brazilian Spiritist Federation, according to a paper I read... It's not the medium's fault that he could have been the target of a case that Spiritists call obsession, meaning that a malicious spirit won't let go of him... or even several spirits presenting themselves under the same name. Allan Kardec explains this very well in the introduction to "The Gospel according to Spiritism" (II. Authority of the Spiritist Doctrine - Universal Control of the teaching of the Spirits) In all of Chico Xavier's work, only what concerns the spirit of André Luís is doubtful because it is incoherent and illogical. He psychographed letters accepted in court in defense of innocent defendants, poems, etc

Translated with DeepL.com (free version) Doc Elisa ^✉ 08:07, 10 March 2024 (UTC)

According to those who follow Spiritism, he was a great medium, but even a great medium can fall into the trap of trickster spirits who make him write about matters of life in the spirit world that have never been revealed to any other medium. This is where the question arises. Would André Luís be a trickster spirit? Or several trickster spirits impersonating the same name? Doc Elisa ^✉ 08:09, 10 March 2024 (UTC)