Talk:Pixel Bath

Latest comment: 2 years ago by QuietHere in topic Fancruft

Fancruft

edit

Figured I should write something about this since @Sagotreespirit just tagged this article with Template:Fansite. First off, to be entirely clear, I haven't listened to this album. I think I heard a song from it once but even if I did I don't remember it. So if the fancruft allegation is being taken literally then let me be clear that it is inaccurate.

Secondly, and more pertinent, clearly there's still a reason why such an allegation would be made, so I would like to ask: what specific improvements are needed here? Most of the article is from the reviews I could find, and as you can see from their ratings they are all positive ones. If that makes the article sound overly positive, perhaps that's just 'cause that's how critics responded to it. It could certainly use more than just those quotes, and that's why I left the list above; I just didn't have time to read all of those. Perhaps enough quotes from those will satisfy the issue. If someone else looked through those (rather than WP:DRIVEBY) then that would be very helpful. QuietHere (talk) 06:17, 23 August 2022 (UTC)Reply