Talk:Rallying/GA1

GA review

Ga on Hold

I'm placing this article on hold, as the lead is 6 paragraphs, and as per WP:LEAD, it shouldn't go beyond five. I don't think this would be complicated to solve, so im not failing it now or anything. Homestarmy 03:54, 13 August 2006 (UTC)

Aw snap, I just checked WP:LEAD and they changed the policy, ok, the "guideline" says it shouldn't go beyond four if it's about 30,000 characters....uhhh...anyone know how many characters this page has? Try to smush the lead together more concisely if you can is the moral of the story here. Homestarmy 03:58, 13 August 2006 (UTC)

GA failed

This GA has been in limbo for far too long, so I'm closing the nomination for now. There are far too few sources, and therfore it's not surprising that there's a tremendous amount of unsourced statements. Some of the sources listed may fit the bill, and it could be that the article just needs more cites. Every statement about the history of the sport should have a source. Every statement explaining the reasons for its popularity should have a source.

I'm also not crazy about the list of different rallies, but that didn't factor into my decision. I'd recommend trying to do something with it before re-nominating. Kafziel 20:19, 7 September 2006 (UTC)