Talk:Rashed Al-Khuzai

Latest comment: 8 years ago by 89.139.132.75 in topic Not a scientific article

Dear CactusWriter.

Regarding the references of prince Rashed Al-Khuzai page I would like to clarify that all these references are clear and documented and there is many web sites for members of Palestinian liberation organization (PLO) stating clearly about the history of Prince Rashed Al-Khuzai like the website of Mr. Mohammad Al-Ramahy (Member of PLO):

[1]


The website of Mr. Muneer Husseiny (member of PLO too):

[2]

And this link for Abdulrahman Tuqan (PLO):

[3]

And this group at facebook that was established by Mr. Nasir Tuqan:

[4]

And please look at the page of Omar Mukhtar and note that it does not state a clear references like the page of Prince Rashed Al-Khuzai, and even the article that was published in Alrai the formal Jordanian news paper kindly read it and translate it well and you will see that it includes many facts about the history of that prince, so please I’m asking you to reserve all the information edited at the page of Prince Rashed Al-Khuzai, and there is another clear reference that is the historical document that was published at Alsabah magazine at Cairo in 29/3/1938 and it is posted at Prince Rashed Al-Khuzai page.

Regards,

Khalid —Preceding unsigned comment added by Khalid Al-Saud (talkcontribs) 19:39, 11 August 2009 (UTC)Reply

Copyrighted text

edit

may you allow me to edit the same article again?

thank you,

Khalid

Dear Targetter

wish you are doing fine.

regarding the article of Prince Rashed Al-Khuzai that i have posted it here I do believe that this article and all included images are not a copyright violation and please check this link for the site which have such a note and including the same information about Prince Rashed, so please kindly reactivate my last article if possible.

Prince Rashed Al Khuzai served palastinian case and i post his history to reveal the hidden facts about his role in all around Islamic and Arabic world.

here is the link stated the note at the end of the article:


http://princerashed.elaphblog.com/posts.aspx?U=2375&A=23336


regards,

Khalid

  • Posting the licensing note on your webpage should clear up the copyright issue, but I'm not an administrator, and an admin must make the final judgement. The content of the article itself must still be looked at for notability, any POV issues and such, but hopefully the article can just be edited. If you would like to work on cleaning up the article, do so at Prince Rashed Al-Khuzai/Temp. Thanks, and good luck! --Targetter (Lock On) 17:56, 3 August 2009 (UTC)Reply
The website does state it releases the information under a GNU free documentation license (GFDL) and CC-BY-SA license. Therefore, there is no copyright violation for using the text from that particular website. However, it does not relieve the article from addressing issues concerning neutral point-of-view, no original research and proper sourcing. Simply repeating information found on an internet blog is not permitted. The text in the article still must have in-line citations to independent reliable sources. Good luck. CactusWriter | needles 12:09, 11 August 2009 (UTC)Reply

Not a scientific article

edit

This article reads like a hagiography, citing from many polemical and non-scientific sources. It also appears to be copying text from other websites (as indicated above). A clue appears in the links: 'His Highness Prince Rashed Al Khuzai Group, it’s a Facebook group created by an American researcher Mr. Nasir M. Tuqan and worldwide teamwork, Houston, TX, USA'. Why is a Facebook fan group being cited as a source here? It seems that someone affiliated with this group is responsible for writing this article, which should be reviewed and edited. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 89.139.132.75 (talk) 17:13, 11 September 2016 (UTC)Reply