Talk:Rhys Williams (Torchwood)/GA1

GA Review

Article (edit | visual edit | history) · Article talk (edit | history) · Watch

Reviewer: Glimmer721 (talk · contribs) 21:06, 9 May 2012 (UTC)

Will review soon. Glimmer721 ^talk 21:06, 9 May 2012 (UTC)

Comments:

• "Rhys' role is increased after the second series; actor Kai Owen is given star billing from Children of Earth onwards" - unlink Kai Owen as he was just linked above; maybe explain that Children of Earth was a serial that made up the third sereis
  • Done, put in parenthesis.
• "The character has went on" → "The character has gone on"
  • Fixed
• "a 2011 BBC/Starz co-production" - BBC doesn't need to be linked again
  • unlinked
• Anwen is linked in the plot summary section, but not the intro
  • linked in intro too. Also linked Gwen in first section of summary for consistency.
• "a contrast to Torchwood's activities and it's charismatic leader Jack Harkness" - "it's" should be "its", and link Jack
  • done.
• Plot summary for "End of Days": briefly explain what the rift is, as it is the first time it has been mentioned. Unless it wasn't the rift after all that erased it from history...
  • mentioned time reset and it being a space-time rift. Think that's all that's needed given that it doesn't relate to much else in the article.
• "Rhys becomes a main character in the third series of Torchwood, a five-part miniseries called Children of Earth airing in 2009." Add bolded word
  • done
• "Series four, Miracle Day (2011) begins..." Comma after "(2011)"
  • done
• "and also has a significant role in The Twilight Streets, (Released March 2008)..." The R in "released" should be lowercase
  • done
• "...after the Torchwood Team fall are destroyed fighting..." Not sure what the word "fall" is doing there
  • removed
• "Rhys makes an appearance in the Torchwood Radio Play..." Don't think "radio play" needs to be capitalized
  • removed capitals and linked
• "With Gwen dead, and Jack missing Rhys is..." No comma after "dead"
  • removed.
• "Rhys also appears in "The Devil and Miss Carew", (2011) an additional radio play, set between" comma after "(2011)" instead of the title; no comma after "play"
  • fixed
• "and that his girlfriends job is nothing more unusual" - "girlfriends" should be "girlfriend's"
  • heh, fixed
• The original intention of the writers had been for Rhys to die at the end of season one but Richard Stokes explains that it was overruled by show creator Russell T Davies" Comma after "season one", link RTD
  • done
• "Actor Kai Owen attributes part of his character's success to his on screen rapport with actress Eve Myles." Hyphen in "on-screen"
  • done
• "After reprisal from death Russell T Davies felt" - comma after "death"
  • done
• Shorten "Russell T Davies" to "Davies" in the second paragraph of "Characterisation"
  • done
• Stephen James Walker is linked twice in "Characterisation"
  • delinked second occurance
• "opining that he, along with Barrowman, Myles and David Lloyd managed..." Isn't there a hyphen in "David-Lloyd"?
  • yep
• "Speaking of the shows fourth series premiere" - "shows" should be "show's"
  • fixed
• References: episode citation should have the "seriesno" and "number" parameters filled out. Also, clarify the titles of the credited people (writer, director, etc)
  • added series/episode numbers and titles in brackets.
• Could the Torchwood Magazine refs be expanded with more parameters filled out?
  • Google is a wonderful thing.
• Ref #49 and #71 need accessdates
  • Put todays. (#48 and #70 since I took a redundant news article out of the series four plot section)
• Ref #72 needs a publisher
  • Added. (#71)
• Disambiguation links
  • Fixed.
• This warns that ref #74 will expire; might want to grab an archive.
  • Included archived version

Putting on hold for 7 days. Pretty minor fixes though; you should be good to go soon! Glimmer721 ^talk 21:57, 9 May 2012 (UTC)

Think I've taken care of everything bar the references, will double check and comment against each point after I get round to filling those out. Thank you for a very comprehensive review! Eshlare (talk) 22:49, 9 May 2012 (UTC)

Update: Just fleshed out all the references where needed. Think everything else has been tackled. Let me know if there's anything I've missed. Thanks again for your time. Eshlare (talk) 00:37, 10 May 2012 (UTC)

Looks like everything has been addressed. Passing! Glimmer721 ^talk 22:00, 10 May 2012 (UTC)