Talk:Sharon Maughan

Latest comment: 1 year ago by James Kevin McMahon in topic Transferred from main article

Ethnic categories

edit

Hi. I've twice removed Category:People of Irish descent in Great Britain from this article. I did this because there is no mention in the article of her ethnicity. I notice her ethnicity is not mentioned in the external links we have either. Per WP:BLP I believe I am exempt from 3RR on removing the category, but I would much prefer to attain consensus here. As far as I see it, we need verifiable references stating that her ethnicity is significant to her notability. If someone can supply those, we can keep the category. Otherwise it will need to go. Thoughts? --John (talk) 23:27, 11 May 2008 (UTC)Reply

Support removal. In this diff, Tony asks "Surname Maughan, born in Liverpool. What evidence would be required?" ... the answer is, a cite from a reliable source stating they are Irish. That would establish they are Irish. We cannot judge ethnicity based on surname or location, sorry, as that is synthesis. (I can give counters to the argument that a surname tells us what ethnicity someone is, without too much trouble) To actually have that fact in the article, though, in my view anyway, requires some demonstration (again, from a reliable source) that the fact that they are of Irish descent is relevant to their biography. Otherwise it is not, just as their shoe size is not typically relevant and their eye color is not typically relevant, and their hair color is not typically relevant. Further reversions of John's removal, without discussion here first, and consensus developed first, may well draw a block. ++Lar: t/c 00:57, 12 May 2008 (UTC)Reply

Transferred from main article

edit

The following unsourced material was removed from the main article, and should only be restored with good references..... She then did rep at the Liverpool Playhouse and Chester, and won her first television opportunity in Philip Mackie's The Organisation, starring Peter Egan. This led to episodes of The Last of the Baskets with Patricia Hayes, then Justice with Margaret Lockwood.

Maughan immediately went on to work with Elaine Stritch, playing the title role in If You Knew Susie, which was part of the TV series Dial M For Murder.

On 19 February 2014, she was part of the invited audience at Buckingham Palace to celebrate the centenary of the Royal Academy of Dramatic Art. She and Trevor were then asked to perform in front of the Queen in the Investiture Room, along with Hugh Laurie, Sir Tom Courtenay and Dame Helen Mirren.[citation needed]

Maughan appeared in her son Jack Eve's debut feature film as writer/director, Death of a Farmer, which having had a screening at the Dinard Film Festival, had its UK Premiere at the Borderlines Film Festival on 5 March 2014.[citation needed] James Kevin McMahon (talk) 14:11, 23 October 2023 (UTC)Reply