Talk:Sherlock Holmes (2014 TV series)

Latest comment: 8 years ago by Reidgreg in topic Copyedit Nov 2016

Copyedit Nov 2016

edit

I've done copyedit on the article. Here is a summary of my changes:

  • I saw there was some British English and tried to use those spelling conventions given the subject matter
  • dmy dates were used in the prose and mdy dates in the list. I changed all of them to dmy for consistency
  • I changed some of the Conan Doyle titles from double quotes to italics, for major works generally following their individual articles and Canon of Sherlock Holmes
  • a fair amount of rephrasing for clarity, conciseness, and grammar
  • there were tone issues in the episode summaries where it indirectly addressed the reader by posing questions – this is unencyclopedic, so I rephrased the sentences
  • There were a few places I was unclear of the meaning and left things as-is.

Issues:

  1. there are three or four passages which are unclear (particularly episode 14 and 16). I marked these with clarify / clarification needed
  2. some information in the lead is out of date
  3. I feel the article could use a bit of organisational work. Information about the adapted characters, for example, is stated in 2-3 places. I feel that could be simplified and the redundancies cut to make for an easier read.
  4. The Citation/Footnote system is unclear. I've added a maintenance banner regarding this.

I'll keep this page on my watchlist for a couple weeks and try to be available for any follow-up. – Reidgreg (talk) 21:58, 12 November 2016 (UTC)Reply