Talk:Soulfly (disambiguation)

Restored disambiguation page

Restored disambiguation page that deleted by User:Amakuru. While I was building it, it was being deleted as non-controversial. Obviously I thought it was needed, so now if it is deleted, place it in the controversial category. Mburrell (talk) 02:00, 12 June 2022 (UTC)

@Mburrell: there has never been a disambiguation page with this name. It is unnecessary, and I did not create any such page. The primary topic is Soulfly, which it has two links at the top, one to Soulfly (Soulfly album) and one to SoulFly (Rod Wave album). There is no link to any disambiguation page there. A disambiguatino is needed for the specific title of Soulfly (album), as it's been determined that there is no primary topic among albums specifically, between the two mentioned above. As such, that page Soulfly (album) has mention of the two albums, to allow readers to choose between the two. There is no reason for any reader to ever navigate to Soulfly (disambiguation), however, and that page has no incoming links or hatnotes so should be deleted. Cheers  — Amakuru (talk) 16:24, 12 June 2022 (UTC)

I stated it badly. There was a redlink to the disambiguation page, and the Soulfly (album) redirected to the redlinked page. I took it upon myself to build the disambiguation page, and when I went to publish, it had all changed, by you, but I did not know your reasoning at first, because your edit summaries were not visible to me until I saved my changes and turned on the watch feature on the various articles. To build the disambiguation page, I went to the disambiguation category and looked over about 20 disambiguation pages, so I know that there are several that have only two links, so I saw that this page fit in. I would prefer a disambiguation page rather than a Soulfly (album) directing page, but that is my preference. Mburrell (talk) 17:54, 12 June 2022 (UTC)