Talk:St. Joseph and Grand Island Railway

Latest comment: 4 years ago by 174.48.95.185 in topic Misleading content

Misleading content

edit

The article on the main page is very poor and misleading. The article gives the impression that the railroad was a short line in Nebraska, while most of the railroad was in Kansas and reached Missouri. I would suggest it be replaced by the following-

The earliest predecessor of the St. Joseph and Grand Island Railroad was the St. Joseph & Western Railroad, chartered by the Territorial legislature of Kansas. Construction began across the Missouri River from St. Joseph, Missouri during 1860. During 1862 the name of the St.J&W was changed to the St. Joseph & Denver City Railroad. By December 1872 it was completed to Hastings, NE, a distance of 227 miles. The name was changed to the St. Joseph & Grand Island Railroad during 1879 following an extension to Grand Island, NE and a connection with the Union Pacific Railroad. Union Pacific gained control of the St. Joseph and Grand Island during 1880. The St. Joseph Bridge Building Company completed a bridge over the Missouri River during 1873, and this was acquired by the St.J&GI during the 1880s. Total length of the railroad from St. Joseph, MO to Grand Island, NE was 249 miles. Union Pacific continues to operate the majority of the former St.J&GI. Abandoned portions run 32 miles between Elwood and Robinson, in Kansas, as well as a segment between Hastings and Grand Island.

And this reference source should be added- http://tacnet.missouri.org/history/encycmo/rrstjoseph.html

Dale Qualicum

The problem is the original author wrote an article about the Hastings and Grand Island RR, not the St Joseph and Grand Island RR. I've totally re-written it to include the 227 miles of railroad the original author ignored. — Preceding unsigned comment added by 174.48.95.185 (talk) 21:40, 3 November 2020 (UTC)Reply