Talk:Toshiko Akiyoshi Trio, 1980 In Rikuzentakata

Song title disagreement / error in CD (cover) printing?

edit

An anonymous Wikipedia editor recently changed the name of track #2 of this album from J. J. Johnson's "Enigma" to (Lane/Harburg's) "Old Devil Moon," commenting, "Track 2 'Enigma' is really 'Old Devil Moon'"

Unfortunately, while this may be correct, the editor provided no source or reference for this change and this information contradicts the previously referenced sources (jazzdisco.org and amazon.jp) which both list track #2 as Johnson's "Enigma." I've tried to find a source for the "Enigma" vs. "Old Devil Moon" change/error but have not found anything yet. I trust the anonymous editor would not have made the change for no reason so can certainly believe it is plausible that the record company misprinted the track listing and/or misidentified the song title on the album cover. But to maintain verifiability, it would be best to find some kind of reference or source to cite for this claimed error.

The same editor switched the track order for tracks #4 and #5 and this change is supported (sort of) by the existing sources insofar as the two sources disagree on this point and only one of them can be correct.

https://www.jazzdisco.org/toshiko-akiyoshi/catalog/#discomate-dsp-8102 ...

  1. Long Yellow Road
  2. Enigma
  3. MC-Talk
  4. I Let A Song Go Out Of My Heart
  5. Two Bass Hit
  6. My Elegy
  7. Autumn Sea
  8. Notorious Tourist From The East
  9. MC-Talk
  10. Tempus Fugit

https://www.amazon.co.jp/dp/B00IHY2LJY ...

  1. 黄色い長い道 10:34 ("Long Yellow Road")
  2. エニグマ 8:55 ("Enigma")
  3. MC・トーク 3:08 (emcee talks 1)
  4. ツー・ベース・ヒット 7:33 ("Two Bass Hit")
  5. 歌を忘れて 6:49 ("I Let A Song Go Out Of My Heart")
  6. マイ・エレジー 7:56 ("My Elegy")
  7. 秋の海 12:08 ("Autumn Sea")
  8. 東部から来た名高き旅行者 8:58 ("Notorious Tourist from the East")
  9. MC・トーク2 4:21 (emcee talks 2)
  10. テンパス・フュージット 6:30 ("Tempus Fugit")

Pugetbill (talk) 00:21, 3 January 2018 (UTC)Reply