Talk:Yosip Khnanisho

Tag

1. No references 2. POV:

• "...family donated to the Church was His Beatitude the late Mar Yosip Khnanishu, God rest his soul, who was called to heaven by his Heavenly Father on Saturday the third of July, 1977, in the city of Baghdad..."
• "On Sunday the 3rd of July 1977, at 1:10 PM. His "Beatitude" (?!) died in Baghdad, Iraq"
• "arrived at St. Mary's Church in Naireya, the final resting-place of this Holy man"
• "then all the mourners paid their last tribute to this beloved shepherd who has left his flock the virtues he possessed such as meekness, love, devotion, kindness, loyalty, forgiveness, integrity, humanity and righteousness. His Sanctified body has been buried in the ground and from his bones flow consolation and solace to the hearts of those who pray in his memory."
• "It was in accordance with this long standing tradition of the Church of the East, the mother of the late Metropolitan Mar Yosip Khnanishu, when conceived with her child, who was dedicated to the service of the Lord, exercised self denial by abstaining from all food prepared from animal meat or meat being one of the ingredients, until the time he was born in 1893. "
• etc.

This article was clearly copied from somewhere else, and it can be a copyvio. I am still letting this hang here for the last month or so, but this article is nothing but a weird propaganda piece. Baristarim 05:39, 31 December 2006 (UTC)

There is too much here that is POV. It reads like a church-published devotional, not an encyclopedia.

I agree. this article must be renewable or deleted. Arthasfleo

I've taken a stab at removing all of the POV language and condensing the article into something more encyclopedic. Since there are no references given, I tried to remove any exceptional claims as well. Hope that's a good start on things. Shell ^babelfish 23:12, 18 April 2008 (UTC)

Saint?

I am unfamiliar with how (if at all) this church formally declares individuals as saints. Please indicate in the article how the subject came to be identified as one. John Carter 19:13, 13 April 2007 (UTC)

Neutral POV !!!

why this article don't sey that this men is consider a Heretic by the most of the Christin world. where is the neutral pov in this article ? This article must be renewable or deleted Arthasfleo

You obviously have no idea what you're talking about, do you?--Rafy talk 17:28, 4 October 2011 (UTC)

Who consecrated him to the episcopate?

Who consecrated him to the episcopate? --Jaques O. Carvalho ☜ 18:13, 15 June 2012 (UTC)