Template:Arbitration case implementation notes/Proposal/testcases

Implementation notes

Clerks and Arbitrators should use this section to clarify their understanding of the final decision—at a minimum, a list of items that have passed. Additionally, a list of which remedies are conditional on others (for instance a ban that should only be implemented if a mentorship should fail), and so on. Arbitrators should not pass the motion to close the case until they are satisfied with the implementation notes.

These notes were last updated by — Wug·a·po·des​ 18:50, 28 July 2022 (UTC); the last edit to this page was on 00:31, 19 September 2024 (UTC) by SilverLocust.

Proposed Principles
Number	Proposal Name	Support	Oppose	Abstain	Status	Support needed	Notes
1	Purpose of Wikipedia	13	0	0		·
2	Healthy and unhealthy conflict	12	0	0		·
3	Consensus	0	13	0		Cannot pass
4	Proposed deletion	13	0	0		·
5	Bludgeoning	4	4	1		Cannot pass	2 equal first choice; One first choice to 5.1; one second choice to 5.1. As 5.1 is passing so 1 is subtracted and also because 5.1 is passing and 5 is failing, votes marked as equal but only for one lead an extra two to be subtracted
5.1	Bludgeoning	9	2	0		·	2 equal first choice with 5; One second choice to 5; One first choice to 5.
6	Battleground conduct	13	0	0		·
7	Repeated behavior	13	0	0		·
Proposed Findings of Fact
Number	Proposal Name	Support	Oppose	Abstain	Status	Support needed	Notes
1	Locus of dispute: Mass creation of articles	11	0	0		·
2	Locus of dispute: Conduct at Articles for Deletion	11	0	0		·
3	7&6=thirteen	11	0	0		·
4	Johnpacklambert sanction history	11	0	0		·
5	Johnpacklambert deletion conduct	11	0	0		·
6	Lugnuts	11	0	0		·
7	TenPoundHammer	11	0	1		·
8	Mass nominations at Articles for Deletion	12	0	1		·
9	Low quality participation at Articles for Deletion	7	0	1		·
10	Battleground behavior at Articles for Deletion	9	0	1		·
11	No evidence for larger issues at Articles for Deletion	0	9	1		·
Proposed Remedies
Number	Proposal Name	Support	Oppose	Abstain	Status	Support needed	Notes
1	7&6=thirteen warned	5	2	1		·
2	7&6=thirteen topic banned	8	1	0		·
3	7&6=thirteen banned	1	5	1		·
4	Johnpacklambert topic banned	9	0	0		·	1 second choice to Johnpacklambert banned
5	Johnpacklambert banned	3	5	0		·
6	Lugnuts warned	7	0	0		·
7	Lugnuts banned	4	3	0		·
8	TenPoundHammer warned	3	3	2		·
9.1	TenPoundHammer topic banned (1)	7	1	1		·
9.2	TenPoundHammer topic banned (2)	3	5	0		·
10	TenPoundHammer banned	2	5	1		·
11	Request for Comment	7	2	0		·
12	Community encouraged	2	5	2		·
Proposed Enforcement
Number	Proposal Name	Support	Oppose	Abstain	Status	Support needed	Notes
0	Enforcement of restrictions	0	0	0		Cannot pass	Passes by default
0	Appeals and modifications	0	0	0		Cannot pass	Passes by default

Notes