| Year | First member | Second member |
|---|---|---|
| 1660 | Sir Anthony Aucher | Heneage Finch,later Earl of Nottingham |
| 1661 | Francis Lovelace | Sir Edward Master |
| 1664 | Thomas Hardres | |
| Feb 1679 | Edward Hales | William Jacob |
| Aug 1679 | Sir Thomas Hardres | |
| 1681 | Lewis Watson | Vincent Denne |
| 1685 | Sir William Honywood, 2nd Baronet | Henry Lee |
| 1695 | George Sayer | |
| 1698 | Henry Lee | |
| 1705 | John Hardres | |
| 1708 | Edward Watson | Sir Thomas D'Aeth, 1st Baronet |
| 1710 | John Hardres | Henry Lee |
| 1715 | Sir Thomas Hales, 2nd Baronet | |
| 1722 | Samuel Milles | |
| 1727 | Sir William Hardres, 4th Baronet | |
| 1734 | Thomas May | |
| 1735 | Sir Thomas Hales, 2nd Baronet | |
| 1741 | Thomas Watson | Thomas Best |
| 1746 | Sir Thomas Hales, 2nd Baronet | |
| 1747 | Matthew Robinson-Morris | |
| 1754 | Sir James Creed | |
| 1761 | Richard Milles | Thomas Best |
| 1768 | William Lynch | |
| 1774 | Sir William Mayne,later Baron Newhaven | |
| 1780 | George Gipps | Charles Robinson |
| 1790 | Sir John Honywood, 4th Baronet | |
| 1796 | John Baker | Samuel Elias Sawbridge |
| Election declared void 2 Mar 1797 | ||
| Mar 1797 | John Baker | Samuel Elias Sawbridge |
| May 1797 | Sir John Honywood | George Gipps |
| 1800 | George Watson | |
| 1802 | John Baker | |
| 1806 | James Simmons | |
| Feb 1807 | Samuel Elias Sawbridge | |
| May 1807 | Edward Taylor | |
| 1812 | Stephen Rumbold Lushington | |
| 1818 | Edward Bligh, Baron Clifton | |
| 1830 | Richard Watson | George Cowper, Viscount Fordwich |
| Jan 1835 | Lord Albert Denison Conyngham | Frederick Villiers |
| Mar 1835 | Stephen Rumbold Lushington | |
| 1837 | James Bradshaw | |
| 1841 | George Smythe | |
| 1847 | Lord Albert Denison Conyngham | |
| 1850 | Frederick Romilly | |
| 1852 | Henry Plumptre Gipps | Henry Butler-Johnstone |
| Constituency representation suspended (1853) | ||
| 1854 | Charles Manners Lushington | Sir William Meredyth Somerville |
| 1857 | Henry Butler-Johnstone | |
| 1862 | Henry Alexander Munro Butler-Johnstone, Conservative | |
| 1865 | John Walter Huddleston, Conservative | |
| 1868 | Theodore Henry Brinckman, Liberal | |
| 1874 | Lewis Ashurst Majendie, Conservative | |
| 1878 | Alfred Erskine Gathorne-Hardy, Conservative | |
| 1879 | Robert Peter Laurie, Conservative | |
| Constituency representation suspended (1880) | ||
