Donegal has 34 All Stars, as of 2019. 22 different players have won, as of 2019. No player has won more than four All Stars. denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1972: Brian McEniff
1974: Donal Monaghan
1983: Martin McHugh
1990: Joyce McMullin
1992: Gary Walsh, Matt Gallagher, Martin Gavigan, Anthony Molloy, Martin McHugh2nd, James McHugh, Tony Boyle
1993: John Joe Doherty
2002: Kevin Cassidy
2003: Adrian Sweeney
2006: Karl Lacey
2009: Karl Lacey2nd
2011: Karl Lacey3rd, Kevin Cassidy2nd, Neil McGee
2012: Paul Durcan, Neil McGee2nd, Karl Lacey 4th, Frank McGlynn, Neil Gallagher, Mark McHugh, Michael Murphy, Colm McFadden
2014: Paul Durcan2nd, Neil McGee3rd, Neil Gallagher2nd, Michael Murphy2nd
2016: Ryan McHugh
2018: Ryan McHugh2nd
2019: Michael Murphy3rd