Down has 23 All Stars, as of 2010. 18 different players have won, as of 2010. Greg Blaney won three All Stars. No player has won more.
1971: Seán O'Neill
1972: Seán O'Neill2nd
1975: Colm McAlarney
1978: Colm McAlarney2nd
1981: Paddy Kennedy
1983: Liam Austin, Greg Blaney
1990: James McCartan Jnr
1991: Conor Deegan, Barry Breen, Ross Carr, Greg Blaney2nd
1994: Miceal Magill, Paul Higgins, DJ Kane, Gregory McCartan, Greg Blaney3rd, James McCartan Jnr2nd, Mickey Linden
2010: Brendan McVeigh, Daniel Hughes, Martin Clarke, Benny Coulter