Legend:
Alaska won RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars season 2.
Detox and Katya were the runners-up.
WIN indicates that the contestant won the challenge and the Lip Sync for Your Legacy.
TOP indicates that the contestant won the challenge, but did not participate in the lip sync.
IN indicates that the contestant won the challenge and the Lip Sync for Your Life, earning re-entry into the competition.
TOP2 indicates that the contestant won the challenge, but lost the Lip Sync for Your Legacy.
SAFE indicates that the contestant was declared safe by the judges.
BTM (Bottom) indicates that the contestant was up for elimination.
ELIM (Eliminated) indicates that the contestant was eliminated.
QUIT indicates that Adore Delano quit the competition.
LOSS indicates that the contestant returned to win re-entry into the competition, but lost.
Guest indicates that the contestant returned as a guest.
| Contestant | Episode | ||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1[1] | 2[2] | 3[3] | 4[4] | 5[5] | 6[6] | 7[7] | 8[8] | 9[9] | |
| Alaska | SAFE | WIN | SAFE | WIN | TOP | WIN | BTM | Winner | Guest |
| Detox | SAFE | BTM | TOP2 | SAFE | TOP | SAFE | WIN | Runner-up | Guest |
| Katya | SAFE | TOP2 | BTM | BTM | SAFE | TOP2 | TOP2 | Runner-up | Guest |
| Roxxxy Andrews | WIN | BTM | SAFE | BTM | BTM | BTM | BTM | Eliminated | Guest |
| Alyssa Edwards | SAFE | SAFE | WIN | ELIM | IN | SAFE | ELIM | Guest | |
| Tatianna | TOP2 | ELIM | IN | ELIM | Guest | ||||
| Phi Phi O'Hara | BTM | SAFE | SAFE | TOP2 | ELIM | ||||
| Ginger Minj | SAFE | SAFE | ELIM | LOSS | Guest | ||||
| Adore Delano | BTM | QUIT | Guest | ||||||
| Coco Montrese | ELIM | LOSS | Guest | ||||||
- ^ "All Star Talent Show Extravaganza". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 2. Episode 1. August 25, 2016. Logo TV.
- ^ "All Stars Snatch Game". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 2. Episode 2. September 1, 2016. Logo TV.
- ^ "HERstory of the World". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 2. Episode 3. September 8, 2016. Logo TV.
- ^ "Drag Movie Shequels". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 2. Episode 4. September 15, 2016. Logo TV.
- ^ "Revenge of the Queens". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 2. Episode 5. September 22, 2016. Logo TV.
- ^ "Drag Fish Tank". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 2. Episode 6. September 28, 2016. Logo TV.
- ^ "Family That Drags Together". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 2. Episode 7. October 6, 2016. Logo TV.
- ^ "All Stars Supergroup". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 2. Episode 8. October 13, 2016. Logo TV.
- ^ "Reunited". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 2. Episode 9. October 27, 2016. Logo TV.