Legend:
Monét X Change and Trinity the Tuck won RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars season 4.
WIN indicates that the contestant won the challenge and the Lip Sync for Your Legacy.
IN indicates that the eliminated contestant won the LaLaPaRuza lip sync and re-entered the competition.
TOP2 indicates that the contestant won the challenge, but lost the Lip Sync for Your Legacy.
STAY indicates that the contestant won the LaLaPaRuza lip sync and remained in the competition.
SAFE indicates that the contestant was declared safe by the judges.
IMM (Immunity) indicates that, having won the previous week's challenge, the contestant was immune from elimination.
BTM (Bottom) indicates that the contestant was up for elimination.
ELIM (Eliminated) indicates that the contestant was eliminated.
LOSS indicates that the contestant lost the LaLaPaRuza lip sync and did not return to the competition.
| Contestant | Episode | |||||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1[1] | 2[2] | 3[3] | 4[4] | 5[5][a] | 6[6] | 7[7] | 8[8] | 9[9] | 10[10] | |
| Monét X Change | SAFE | TOP2 | SAFE | BTM | WIN | IMM | SAFE | TOP2 | BTM | Winner |
| Trinity the Tuck | WIN | SAFE | TOP2 | SAFE | BTM | STAY | TOP2 | SAFE | WIN | Winner |
| Monique Heart | TOP2 | BTM | SAFE | WIN | BTM | STAY | SAFE | SAFE | TOP2 | Eliminated |
| Naomi Smalls | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | BTM | STAY | BTM | WIN | BTM | Eliminated |
| Latrice Royale | SAFE | SAFE | SAFE | ELIM | IN | WIN | BTM | ELIM | ||
| Manila Luzon | SAFE | SAFE | WIN | TOP2 | WIN | IMM | SAFE | ELIM | ||
| Valentina | SAFE | WIN | BTM | SAFE | BTM | STAY | ELIM | |||
| Gia Gunn | SAFE | SAFE | ELIM | LOSS | ||||||
| Farrah Moan | BTM | ELIM | LOSS | |||||||
| Jasmine Masters | ELIM | LOSS | ||||||||
- Notes
- ^ After the fifth episode's lip sync, RuPaul declared that All Stars rules would be temporarily suspended and nobody would be going home.
- ^ "All Star-Spangled Variety Show". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 1. December 14, 2018. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.
- ^ "Super Girl Groups, Henny!". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 2. December 21, 2018. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.
- ^ "Snatch Game of Love". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 3. December 28, 2018. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.
- ^ "Jersey Justice". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 4. January 4, 2019. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.
- ^ "Roast in Peace". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 5. January 11, 2019. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.
- ^ "LaLaPaRuZa". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 6. January 18, 2019. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.
- ^ "Queens of Clubs". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 7. January 25, 2019. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.
- ^ "RuPaul's Best Judy's Race". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 8. February 1, 2019. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.
- ^ "Sex and the Kitty, Girl 3". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 9. February 8, 2019. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.
- ^ "Super Queen". RuPaul's Drag Race All Stars. Season 4. Episode 10. February 15, 2019. VH1 / WOW Presents Plus.