Galway has 43 All Stars, as of 2022. 29 different players have won, as of 2022. No player has won more than three All Stars. denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1971: P. J. Smyth, Jack Cosgrove, Liam Sammon, Seamus Leydon
1972: Tommy Joe Gilmore
1973: Liam O'Neill, Tommy Joe Gilmore2nd, Liam Sammon2nd
1974: Johnny Hughes, Tom Naughton, John Tobin
1976: Johnny Hughes2nd
1981: Séamus McHugh, Barry Brennan
1983: Stephen Kinneavy
1984: Séamus McHugh2nd
1987: Val Daly
1990: Val Daly2nd
1995: Jarlath Fallon
1998: Martin McNamara, Tomás Mannion, Seán Óg De Paor, Kevin Walsh, Michael Donnellan, Jarlath Fallon 2nd, Pádraic Joyce
2000: Declan Meehan, Michael Donnellan2nd, Pádraic Joyce2nd, Derek Savage
2001: Kieran Fitzgerald, Declan Meehan 2nd, Seán Óg De Paor2nd, Kevin Walsh2nd, Michael Donnellan3rd, Pádraic Joyce3rd
2003: Kevin Walsh3rd
2018: Ian Burke
2022: Liam Silke, John Daly, Cillian McDaid, Damien Comer, Shane Walsh