Template:Mayo All Stars record

Mayo has 54 All Stars, as of 2021. 33 different players have won, as of 2021. Lee Keegan has won the most All-Stars with five.   denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.

1971: Johnny Carey
1979: Joe McGrath
1985: Dermot Flanagan, Willie Joe Padden, Kevin McStay
1989: Gabriel Irwin, Jimmy Browne, Dermot Flanagan^2nd, Willie Joe Padden^2nd, Noel Durkin
1992: T. J. Kilgallon
1993: Kevin O'Neill
1996: Kenneth Mortimer, Pat Holmes, James Nallen, Liam McHale, James Horan
1997: Kenneth Mortimer^2nd, Pat Fallon
1999: James Horan^2nd
2004: James Nallen^2nd, Ciarán McDonald
2006: Alan Dillon, Conor Mortimer
2011: Andy Moran
2012: Ger Cafferkey, Keith Higgins, Lee Keegan, Alan Dillon^2nd
2013: Keith Higgins^2nd, Lee Keegan^2nd, Colm Boyle, Aidan O'Shea
2014: Keith Higgins^3rd, Colm Boyle^2nd, Cillian O'Connor
2015: Lee Keegan^3rd, Aidan O'Shea^2nd
2016: David Clarke, Brendan Harrison,  Lee Keegan ^4th, Colm Boyle^3rd
2017: David Clarke^2nd, Chris Barrett, Keith Higgins^3rd Colm Boyle^4th, Aidan O'Shea^3rd,  Andy Moran ^2nd
2019: Paddy Durcan
2020: Oisín Mullin, Cillian O'Connor^2nd
2021: Lee Keegan^5th, Matthew Ruane, Ryan O'Donoghue