Tyrone has 57 All Stars, as of 2021. 33 different players have won, as of 2021. Peter Canavan and Seán Cavanagh won eleven All Stars between them. denotes that a player also won Footballer of the Year for the year in question.
1980: Kevin McCabe
1984: Eugene McKenna, Frank McGuigan
1986: John Lynch, Plunkett Donaghy, Damien O'Hagan, Eugene McKenna2nd
1989: Eugene McKenna3rd
1994: Peter Canavan
1995: Fay Devlin, Peter Canavan 2nd
1996: Finbar McConnell, Peter Canavan3rd
2001: Stephen O'Neill
2002: Peter Canavan4th
2003: Cormac McAnallen, Conor Gormley, Philip Jordan, Seán Cavanagh, Brian Dooher, Brian McGuigan, Peter Canavan5th
2004: Seán Cavanagh2nd
2005: Ryan McMenamin, Conor Gormley2nd, Philip Jordan2nd, Seán Cavanagh3rd, Brian Dooher2nd, Peter Canavan6th, Owen Mulligan, Stephen O'Neill 2nd
2008: Conor Gormley3rd, Justin McMahon, David Harte, Philip Jordan3rd, Enda McGinley, Brian Dooher3rd, Seán Cavanagh 4th
2009: Stephen O'Neill3rd
2010: Philip Jordan4th
2013: Seán Cavanagh5th
2015: Mattie Donnelly
2016: Mattie Donnelly2nd, Peter Harte
2017: Colm Cavanagh
2018: Colm Cavanagh2nd, Pádraig Hampsey
2019: Ronan McNamee, Cathal McShane
2021: Niall Morgan, Pádraig Hampsey2nd, Conor Meyler, Kieran McGeary , Peter Harte2nd, Brian Kennedy, Niall Sludden, Darren McCurry