The Church of the Good Thief is the third and final release from Andy Hull's solo project, Right Away, Great Captain!, which follows the journey of a 17th-century sailor. From Right Away, Great Captain!'s Myspace blog: "The third story/album starts with our hero laying over Anna's lover (and hero's brother). The brother has been killed. His wife has seen what the children saw and we spend a lot of time inside our hero's mind and the reality that he is indeed a murderer of his own flesh and blood."[3] The album was released on June 12, 2012.
- "Blame" - 3:46
- "When I Met Death" - 2:58
- "I Am Aware" - 3:10
- "Old Again" - 2:58
- "Fur Stop Caring" - 2:57
- "I Wait For You" - 4:48
- "Barely Bit Me" - 3:00
- "Rotten Black Root" - 3:31
- "We Were Made Out Of Lightning" - 4:24
- "Memories From The End Pt. 1" - 3:40
- "Memories From The End Pt. 2" - 3:28