The Phoney Victory: The World War II Illusion is a book by Peter Hitchens. It was published in August 2018 by I.B. Tauris. The book addresses what Hitchens regards as the national myth of the Second World War, which he believes dealt long-term damage to Britain and its position in the world.
 | |
| Author | Peter Hitchens |
|---|---|
| Subject | British politics, World War II |
| Genre | Non-fiction |
| Publisher | I.B. Tauris |
Publication date | 29 August 2018 |
| Publication place | United Kingdom |
| Pages | 240 |
| ISBN | 9781788313292 |
| Preceded by | Short Breaks in Mordor |
| Followed by | Unconventional Wisdom |
He argues that while the Allies were, indeed, fighting a radical evil, they sometimes used immoral methods, such as the Allies' carpet bombing of German civilians. He believes that Britain's entry into World War II led to its rapid decline after the war. This was because, among other things, it could not finance the war and was not prepared. As a result, it had to surrender much of its wealth and power to avoid bankruptcy.[1] However, Hitchens does not make a universal anti-war case because he believes that this position often leaves countries unprotected and defenceless in times of war. Instead, he argues that military power and the threat of war can be necessary deterrents against war.[2]
Reception
editThe book was negatively reviewed by Richard J. Evans, former Regius Professor of Modern History at the University of Cambridge, in the New Statesman. Evans described the book as being "riddled with errors" and reliant "on a handful of eccentric studies".[3] At the Edinburgh International Book Festival, Hitchens responded to this review, "It was reviewed... by somebody who actually honestly believed it was a Eurosceptic book written to please the patriotic readers of The Mail on Sunday; any reader of it who actually gets to the end may find this to be, how shall I put it, a possibly mistaken summary."[4] Hitchens also responded to Evans' review on his blog, calling it "shocking" and "very poor", and pointing to what he saw as serious errors in Evans' critiques.[5]
Daniel Johnson writing in Standpoint disagreed with many of the claims made in the book, and compared it negatively to the recent book Churchill: Walking with Destiny, which Johnson said refuted Hitchens' "claim that the whole conflict was unnecessary".[6]
References
edit- ^ Giovanni, Charles (14 January 2019). ""The Phoney Victory - Reviewed by Charles Giovanni, Vanzan Coutinho, New York"".
- ^ Maiolo, Joseph (2 November 2018). ""Myth understanding - Trying to make sense of the Second World War"".
- ^ Evans, Richard J. (26 September 2018). "Peter Hitchens's Eurosceptic take on the Second World War is riddled with errors and bizarre theories". New Statesman. Retrieved 18 October 2018.
- ^ Peter Hitchens speaks to Ruth Wishart at the Edinburgh International Book Festival (5:38), retrieved 2022-10-11
- ^ https://hitchensblog.mailonsunday.co.uk/2018/09/a-reply-to-the-knighted-professor-his-review-of-my-book-is-a-very-poor-piece-of-work-.html
- ^ Johnson, Daniel (2 October 2018). "A martial nation needs Churchill to inspire us - Standpoint". Standpoint. Archived from the original on 2 August 2019. Retrieved 18 October 2018.