Tip Project was a business venture and organization which unsuccessfully pushed to introduce American practices of gratuity into Japanese culture. First launched in 2021 and managed by the Tip Promotion Association, it was shut down in the first half of 2023.
 | |
| Industry | Hospitality |
|---|---|
| Founded | 2021 |
| Founder | Yoshihito Kamogashira |
| Defunct | 2023 |
| Website | tip-culture.com (archived) |
Background
editJapan was previously noted as a culture where gratuity practices largely did not exist. Numerous travel agencies, blogs, and companies have written about how in Japan, tipping is considered either something that should not be practiced, or in some cases, considered to be rude.[1] In restaurants and food service, where American tipping is most common and prevalent for the reasons of waiters usually not making a living wage and the United States' minimum wage laws enabling workers who frequently receive gratuity to be paid a lower wage than most employees, Japanese culture treats good service as something to be expected by default and not rewarded. Cultural customs also traditionally give Japanese food service workers at least one free meal per worked day.[2] The only Japanese workers who traditionally receive gratuities are highly-personal staff, such as geishas and workers in ryokan hotels, though these workers frequently receive their gratuity similar to Chinese red envelopes rather than standalone cash.[3][4]
Tip Project came at about the same time as Japanese taxi drivers giving the ability for riders to add gratuity. The effort was started by Japanese taxi operator Sanwa Kotsu in collaboration with the Respo company, a digital tipping firm; Sanwa Kotsu has previously recorded instances of the company's drivers receiving tips.[5] Prior to Tip Project and the taxi driver tipping system, the only gratuity forms in Japan to gain traction was in a form of origami tips, where service workers were handed custom origami sculptures made from chopstick wrappers as gratuity.[6]
Project history
editBeginnings
editThe project was founded in early 2021 by Yoshihito Kamogashira, a Japanese YouTuber. Kamogashira started the project because he believed that American tipping practices would help raise the self-esteem and happiness of Japanese service industry workers who were severely affected by the COVID-19 pandemic. The project also believes that the creation of the system will enable businesses to succeed not solely on the number of customers it receives.[7][8]
Business model and promotion
editTip Project's primary source of revenue came from selling branded paper slips and supplementary goods, with the slips known as "tip tickets". These tip tickets read "premium Japan tip", which featured the tipper's name, the recipient server or worker's name, as well as an amount to be tipped in yen. The project noted that at least ten restaurants signed onto the idea.[8]
One of the ways Tip Project promoted its practices was by producing and marketing a video in which the project's recommended usage of its tip tickets is used. In the video, set in a restaurant, a waiter offers a guest a blanket, though instead of vocally expressing her gratitude, decides to fill out a tip ticket.[9][10]
Reception
editPre-failure
editThe backlash against the project was immediate. Translations of Japanese comments in a Kotaku article that covered the project read "This doesn't suit Japan" and "This is a pain in the ass". One comment suggested that if 20% was the standard tip, discount all prices by 20%.[8]
Dissolution
editTip Project vanished in 2023. The Financial Times celebrated the failure of Tip Project, with columnist Leo Lewis writing that the project's failure was a rare time when people should "relish the failure of a business venture". Lewis proceeds to describe the failure of Tip Project as Japan's culture being spared from a social "tyranny", in comparison to the overly-high gratuity amounts given in American culture. Lewis draws the ultimate conclusion that tipping is a fundamentally "un-Japanese" practice.[11]
References
edit- ^ "Tipping Culture in Japan and China - Start Travel". www.starttravel.co.uk. Retrieved 2023-03-28.
- ^ "Tipping in Japan? Not So Much a Thing | Frommer's". www.frommers.com. Retrieved 2023-03-28.
- ^ "Tipping in Japan: When They Are and Aren't Accepted". alljapantours.com. Retrieved 2023-03-28.
- ^ webmaster. "Tipping in Japan: There is no tipping culture in Japan – Toranomon Language School". Retrieved 2023-03-28.
- ^ "Time for Japan to start tipping taxi drivers? Cab company now gives passengers option in Tokyo". SoraNews24 -Japan News-. 2021-07-20. Retrieved 2023-03-29.
- ^ Taggart, Emma (2017-12-25). "13,000 Origami Sculptures Made From Chopstick Sleeves Left as "Tips" in Japan". My Modern Met. Retrieved 2023-03-29.
- ^ "tip-culture.com". 2022-01-27. Archived from the original on 2022-01-27. Retrieved 2023-03-29.
- ^ a b c "A Japanese Company Plans To Promote Tipping Culture In Japan Through Tip Tickets - Japan Inside". 2021-10-26. Retrieved 2023-03-29.
- ^ チップ普及協会イメージムービー, retrieved 2023-03-29
- ^ "Tipping In Japan? One Company Aims To Spread It Throughout The Country". Kotaku. 2021-10-20. Retrieved 2023-03-29.
- ^ Lewis, Leo (2023-03-26). "Japan remains free from the tyranny of tipping". Financial Times. Retrieved 2023-03-29.
External links
edit- Official website, archived from the original (now offline)
- Promotional video