Trail of Lightning is a 2018 fantasy novel, the debut novel by Rebecca Roanhorse. After a supernatural disaster destroys most of North America, Navajo monster-slayer Maggie Hoskie must navigate a world of monsters and gods. The novel won the 2019 Locus Award for Best First Novel and was nominated for the Hugo, World Fantasy, and Nebula awards.
 First edition cover art | |
| Author | Rebecca Roanhorse |
|---|---|
| Cover artist | Tommy Arnold |
| Language | English |
| Series | The Sixth World |
| Genre | Fantasy; Speculative fiction |
| Publisher | Saga Press |
Publication date | 2018 |
| Media type | |
| Pages | 287 |
| Awards | Locus Award for Best First Novel |
| ISBN | 9781534413498 1st e |
| OCLC | 1003489349 |
| 813/.6 | |
| LC Class | PS3618.O283 T73 2018 |
| Followed by | Storm of Locusts |
Plot summary
editIn the 21st century, a worldwide flood caused by multiple earthquakes along the New Madrid fault line destroys most of the United States as magic returns to the world. Dinétah becomes an independent nation. Certain Navajo people develop clan powers based on their ancestral tribes.
On Maggie Hoskie's sixteenth birthday, her grandmother is murdered by witches and monsters. This traumatic event activates her clan powers, giving Maggie superhuman speed and a propensity for killing. She attracts the attention of the immortal monster-slayer Neizghání and becomes his apprentice. Neizghání trains her in the art of combat, but abandons her when he perceives that she is becoming too violent. Maggie becomes a bounty hunter and monster-slayer. She seeks information about a new breed of monster from Tah, a local medicine man. Tah tells her that the monster was created by a powerful witch. He asks her to work with his grandson Kai Arviso, who also possesses clan powers, to destroy the witch.
Maggie and Kai retrieve information about a relic known as a "fire drill", which may be related to the monsters. She is visited by Mąʼii, the Coyote; Mąʼii tells her that the drill belongs to Mósí, a cat goddess. He also requests that she complete a task for him, giving her magical rings. Tah's hogan burns down; Maggie suspects Neizghání. In the carnage, Maggie and Kai kill a corrupt police officer. They seek shelter with Grace Goodacre, a local bar owner. Maggie, Kai, and Grace's children begin working together.
Mósí promises to give the fire drill to the winner of a duel. Maggie agrees and is ordered to fight Neizghání. He brands her and almost kills her, but she is rescued by Kai. Maggie seeks revenge against Neizghání, believing him to be responsible for the death of Tah and the creation of the monsters. They return to Black Mesa, where Maggie last saw Neizghání.
As Kai and the Goodacres are ambushed by monsters on Black Mesa, Mąʼii appears and reveals to Maggie that he controls the monsters. He was responsible for the murder of her grandmother, leading to the activation of her clan powers; he was also responsible for Maggie's duel with Neizghání. He wants to forge Maggie into a powerful warrior. Furious at this revelation, Maggie kills him and returns to the battlefield, where Neizghání has defeated the monsters and is now threatening Kai, whom he considers to be a rival. Neizghání offers Maggie a choice: fight and die now, or betray Kai and return to him. Maggie kills Kai, believing that his clan powers will resurrect him. She then uses Mąʼii's rings to bind Neizghání, temporarily incapacitating him and removing his powers. At Maggie's trailer, Tah and Maggie wait for Kai to return.
Background
editRebecca Roanhorse began writing fantasy as a hobby while pursuing a career as a lawyer. She stated that when she was unable to find a science fiction or fantasy novel with a Native American protagonist, she decided to write one, saying in 2019 that many Native American fictional characters are portrayed as stuck in the past, and she wanted to use her novel to show Native characters as "alive and thriving".[1] Roanhorse has said that she is of Ohkay Owingeh Pueblo descent through her mother's family, and African American on her father's side.[2] When she began publishing and doing speaking engagements, others pointed out that she is not an enrolled member of any tribal community.[2] Leaders of the Ohkay Owingeh community have stated that Roanhorse is not enrolled there and has no connection to their community.[3]
Reception and awards
editTrail of Lightning received mostly positive reviews from non-Native critics. The Verge called it a "much-needed perspective to the larger canon of fantasy fiction", praising it for its portrayal of Native American characters.[4] Critics also praised Trail of Lightning for its fast-paced action and complex characters.[5][6] Locus called the novel "immensely readable and very enjoyable" and praised it for its worldbuilding; it also criticized the novel for shallow dialogue and a disjointed plot structure.
The Diné Writers' Collective criticized the novel as cultural appropriation, stating that someone who is not a recognized member of the Diné tribal community "does not have the authority or experience to write about our people and culture". They feel that important Navajo spiritual beliefs were portrayed inaccurately and offensively.[3] They also criticized the way in which some book reviewers, based on the author's writings, have conflated different tribes of Native Americans into one identity.[7] Dr. Matthew Martinez, former Lieutenant Governor of Ohkay Owingeh (the tribal community the author claims descent from, but who do not claim her),[8][9][3] said, "by not engaging in any form of cultural and community acknowledgement, Roanhorse has failed to establish any legitimate claim to call herself Ohkay Owingeh." He eventually concluded, "It is unethical for Roanhorse to be claiming Ohkay Owingeh and using this identity to publish Native stories."[3]
Trail of Lightning won the 2019 Locus Award for Best First Novel, [10] and was a finalist for the Nebula Award for Best Novel of 2018,[11] the 2019 World Fantasy Award for Best Novel,[12] and the 2019 Hugo Award for Best Novel.[13]
References
edit- ^ Kyle Muzyka (14 April 2019). "A correction of stereotypes: Rebecca Roanhorse's post-apocalyptic books draw on Indigenous experience". Canadian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 11 August 2019.
- ^ a b Lila Shapiro (October 20, 2020). "The Sci-Fi Author Reimagining Native History". Vulture.
- ^ a b c d Agoyo, Acee (24 June 2020). "'The Elizabeth Warren of the sci-fi set': Author faces criticism for repeated use of tribal traditions". Indianz. Archived from the original on 1 Oct 2020. Retrieved 2 June 2023.
- ^ Liptak, Andrew (26 June 2018). "Trail of Lightning is a breathtaking Native American urban fantasy adventure". The Verge. Retrieved 11 August 2019.
- ^ "Fiction Book Review: Trail of Lightning by Rebecca Roanhorse". Publishers Weekly. Retrieved 11 August 2019.
- ^ "TRAIL OF LIGHTNING by Rebecca Roanhorse". Kirkus Reviews. 18 June 2018. Retrieved 11 August 2019.
- ^ Esther Belin; et al. (5 November 2018). "Trail of Lightning is an appropriation of Diné cultural beliefs". Indian Country Today. Archived from the original on 2021-02-21.
- ^ Huynh, Hamy (17 Dec 2018). "Q&A with First Lieutenant Governor and CLA Alum Matthew Martinez". University of Minnesota. Archived from the original on 3 Oct 2020. Retrieved 2 June 2023.
- ^ Chacón, Daniel J. (13 May 2023). "Former Ohkay Owingeh governor remembered as fierce champion with kind heart". The Santa Fe New Mexican. Retrieved 2 June 2023.
- ^ "2019 Locus Awards Winners". Locus. 29 June 2019. Retrieved 11 August 2019.
- ^ "2019 Nebula Award Nominees". 20 February 2019. Retrieved 11 August 2019.
- ^ "World Fantasy Awards 2019". Retrieved 11 August 2019.
- ^ "2019 Hugo Award Finalists Announced". Tor.com. 2 April 2019. Retrieved 11 August 2019.