Original Article Evaluation (Original deleted)
The original article is a stub. It lacks citations including primary sources and cites an unreliable secondary source. In addition, it is not divided into sections, consisting solely of one paragraph. In addition, the article makes a number of unsubstantiated claims (e.g. "Red is the dominant color of both Chantico’s clothes and her face.). The article also describes Chantico in very subjective terms (e.g. "she is very defensive"). The article also fails to mention debates surrounding Chantico and does not discuss how Chantico is described in sixteenth century texts such as Sahagún's writings.
This user is a student editor in Yale_University/HSAR_415_Aztec_Art_and_Architecture_(Fall_2018). |