Francis Macnab
editTheology
edit"A New Faith"
edit
Dr Macnab told the 16 September 2008 edition of the Age, "The old faith is in large sections unbelievable. We want to make the new faith more believable, realistic and helpful in terms of the way people live". The new faith was launched with a $120,000 advertising campaign including posters reading, "The Ten Commandments, one of the most negative documents ever written."[1][2] Dr Macnab described Moses as a mass murderer, Abraham as concocted and Jesus as a Jewish peasant and certainly not God. [1]
Reaction
edit
The Moderator of the Synod of Victoria and Tasmania, Rev Kioa described Dr Macnab's comments challenging the divinity of Jesus as questioning some of the faith's most basic beliefs, turning away from 2000 years of "orthodox Christian belief."[2][3][4] Other members of the Synod published their concerns.[5][6]
The Synod of Victoria and Tasmania voted to request St Michael's Uniting Church to remove advertising for its new faith and apologise to Jews, Christians and Muslims for the comments it contained about the Ten Commandments.[7][2] The Uniting Church did not move to discipline Dr Macnab because no formal complaint had been received.[3][2]
The Session of Scots' Church published a reply defending the Ten Commandments from "[t]he most incredible publicity war... being waged against the historic Christian faith."[8] They installed a poster outlining the influence of the Ten Commandments on their Russell Street frontage facing towards St. Michael's.
Dr Macnab's response
editIn a interview with Stateline Victoria Dr Macnab replied to criticism saying that he was in agreement with others inside Christianity who, "are asking the traditional church to re-examine and renew their basic thinking about what faith can be, because millions of people do not find the old faith meaningful to their lives."[3] He said he "would expect that kind of reaction from people who take the scriptures far too literally."[2]
In an address on 5 October Dr Macnab defended his comments, including against suggestions they were offensive to Jews, citing his study in undergraduate and postgraduate work in Hebrew language and history, including distinctions, and saying "Some of the comments have been knee-jerk reactions, uninformed and heavily overloaded with bad manners."[9] He also stated, "While I have no intention of denigrating the Ten Commandments as a sacred symbol of the Jewish Torah and the Old Covenant, I say they are negative."[9] He gave 8 reasons why he believes the Ten Commandments to be negative, and outlined his alternative 10 Commandments, which he described as "positive, plausible and powerful"[9]: [10]
References
edit- ^ a b Barney Zwartz (2008-09-16). "New faith throws out the Ten Commandments". The Age. Fairfax. Retrieved 2008-09-26.
- ^ a b c d e Hall, Cheryl (2008-10-05). "Controversial clergyman advertises his new faith on billboards". Stateline Victoria. The Australian Broadcasting Corporation. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- ^ a b c Zwartz, Barney (2008-09-22). "Gentle rebuke over minister's 'new faith'". The Age. Fairfax Digital. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
- ^ "Who's Who in the News: Francis Macnab". Who's Who News Archive. Crown Content Pty Ltd. 2008-09-16. Retrieved 2008-09-27.
- ^ Rev Sue Gorman (2008-09-16). "Statement of Pastoral Concern" (PDF). The Uniting Church of Australia, Synod of Victoria and Tasmania. Retrieved 2008-09-26.
The Uniting Church is committed to an understanding of God as the Holy Trinity and to Jesus Christ as Son of God, Saviour and Lord. To describe him as 'just a Jewish peasant' falls very far short of the church's classic statements of belief in him. Similarly, to reduce God to 'a presence beyond ourselves' is a serious under-statement of the church's belief in the God who is creator, redeemer and perfecter of all things.
- ^ Rev Professor Chris Mostert (2008-09-16). "A theological response to comments made by Dr Francis Macnab, The Age, 16 September 2008" (PDF). The Uniting Church of Australia, Synod of Victoria and Tasmania. Retrieved 2008-09-26.
- ^ "Remove offensive signs and offer apology, says church". Website of the Synod of Victoria and Tasmania. Uniting Church in Australia. 2008-09-. Retrieved 2008-09-26.
{{cite web}}: Check date values in:|date=(help) - ^ "The Ten Commandments". Scots' Church website. The Session of Scots' Church. Retrieved 2008-10-10.
The Ten Commandments: the most positive and influential document ever written. More than 3000 years of history that engender and promote: respect for the Divine Creator, which saves us from the arrogance of our humanity as we enjoy and make use of his creation, respect for the Divine character, which saves us from misplaced trust in the frivolous and transient gods of our age, respect for the name of God, which teaches us humility and service, respect for the spiritual nurture of our soul, because we are more than an accident of nature, respect for family and especially parents, respect for life, seeking to nurture and value all people, including the weak, the marginalised and the displaced, respect for our spouse, for the sanctity of marriage and for the value of commitment, respect for property and the rights of other people, taking nothing to ourselves that is not ours, respect for the truth, including the value of rational, scientific enquiry as well as the gospel truth about God and his Son Jesus Christ, respect for personal integrity and the purity of our hearts' desires
- ^ a b c Francis Macnab (2008-10-05). "The New Faith and 10 New Commandments". St Michael's Uniting Church. Retrieved October 25, 2008.
- ^ Francis Macnab (2008-10-05). "The New Faith and 10 New Commandments". St Michael's Uniting Church. Retrieved October 25, 2008.
1. Believe in a Good Presence in your life. Call that Good Presence: God, G-D - and follow that Good presence so that you live life fully - tolerantly, collaboratively, generously and with dignity. 2. Believe in a God-Presence in your life that will lift you constantly to live harmoniously in yourself and with others, always searching for your best health and happiness. 3. Take care of your home, your environments, your Planet and its vital resources for the life and health of people in all the world. 4. Be kind and caring of the animals, the birds, and the creatures of land and the rivers and the seas. 5. Help people develop their potential and become as fully functioning human beings as is possible from birth, through traumas and triumph to the end of their days. 6. Be magnanimous and excessive in your support of good causes, and use your affluence and material goods and scientific skills in altruistic concern for the future of the world. 7. Study ways to encourage and sustain the dignity, hope and integrity of all human beings and study ways to help all human beings embrace their dignity, hope, and integrity. 8. Be alive to new possibilities, new ways, and to the unfolding mysteries and wonders of life and the world. 9. We often focus our lives on many things and pursuits that promise our fulfilment. Study the deeper things of the Spirit, and the things of ultimate concern for all human beings. Be part of an evolving life-enhancing Faith that will also bring a new resilience to the future. 10. Take time to worship the great Source of all the positive transforming energies of life, and search to be at one with "the spirit of the good, the tender and the beautiful.{{cite web}}: line feed character in|quote=at position 204 (help)