| Position | Contestant | Team | Status | Merge |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 16-15 | Geoff | Host of TDA Aftermath | Eliminated 1st/2nd in Episode 2 "Alien Resurr-eggtion" |
Non-Merged |
| Bridgette | Hostess of TDA Aftermath | Non-Merged | ||
| 14 | Izzy / E-Scope |
The Killer Grips | Eliminated 3rd in Episode 3 "Riot on Set" |
Non-Merged |
| 13 | Trent | The Killer Grips (1st Captain) |
Eliminated 4th in Episode 5 "3:10 to Crazytown" |
Non-Merged |
| 12 | Gwen | The Screaming Gaffers (1st Captain) |
Eliminated 5th in Episode 7 "The Chefshank Redemption" |
Non-Merged |
| 11 | DJ | The Screaming Gaffers | Quit 1st/Eliminated 6th in Episode 9 "The Sand Witch Project" |
Non-Merged |
| 10 | Izzy / Explosivo |
The Killer Grips | Eliminated 7th in Episode 11 "Full Metal Drama" |
Non-Merged |
| * | Owen (I) | The Killer Grips | Eliminated 8th in Episode 13 "Ocean's Eight - or nine" |
Returns in "Rock n' Rule" |
| 9 | Heather | The Screaming Gaffers | Eliminated 9th in Episode 15 "Million Dollar Babies" |
Non-Merged |
| 8 | LeShawna | The Screaming Gaffers | Eliminated 10th in Episode 17 "Super Hero-ld" |
Merged Team |
| 7 | Justin | The Killer Grips | Eliminated 11th in Episode 19 "The Princess Pride" |
Merged Team |
| 6 | Lindsay | The Killer Grips |
Eliminated 12th in Episode 21 "Rock n' Rule" |
Merged Team |
| 5 | Harold | The Screaming Gaffers | Eliminated 13th in Episode 23 "2008: A Space Owen" |
Merged Team |
| 4 | Courtney | The Killer Grips | Eliminated 14th in Episode 24 "Top Dog" |
Merged Team |
| 3 | Owen (II) | The Killer Grips |
Eliminated 15th in Episode 24 "Top Dog" |
Merged Team |
| 2 | Duncan | The Screaming Gaffers |
Runner Up in Episode 25 "Mutiny on the Soundstage" |
Merged Team |
| 1 | Beth | The Killer Grips |
Winner in Episode 25 "Mutiny on the Soundstage" |
Merged Team |
